Conversation with a Creationist
by Ranse Traxler
There are just some things that are too memorable for a person to
forget. A few years ago I had such an experience at one of the monthly
meetings of the Missouri Association for Creation is St. Louis. Even
though I consider myself something of a "wordsmith" (you should hear the
words I can come up with when I hit my thumb while hammering), the
following is something too "unusual" for me to have created. I swear it
took place.
The event would be memorable already because of something David
Menton, President of MAC, Washington University professor, and Technical
Advisor to the ICR [Institute for Creation Research], said in response
to a question from the audience. When the topic of embryonic features
was brought up, he replied, "Look! I'm a professor of anatomy at
Washington University Medical School, and I assure you that at no time
during development does a human embryo have anything remotely resembling
a tail or gill slits!"
During that meeting I noticed a young female who looked very out of
place there; she had a Levis jacket loaded with pins, spiked hair, and
all sorts of chains and medals around her neck. After the meeting I
happened to meet her in the parking lot and we started to talk.
She: "I came to the meeting tonight to learn more about
evolution."
I: "Would you want to learn more about God by asking the
Devil? You should instead talk with a biologist at one of
the local universities. You need to ask someone with a good
science background to learn more about evolution."
She: "Oh, I have a good science background. I'm a nursing
major at [a local junior college]."
I: "What do you know about evolution?"
She: "Well, if evolution is true, then I ought to be able
to walk down the street and see a dog turn into a cat."
I: "That's not what evolution says. Evolution says that
dogs and cats have a common ancestor. Let me give you an
example: you and your cousin have a common ancestor, a
grandmother, right?"
She: "Yes, but she's not a monkey."
I: "No one is saying your grandmother is a monkey. All I'm
saying is that dogs and cats share a common ancestor just
like you and your cousin share your grandmother as a common
ancestor."
She: "But she's not a monkey!"
I: I'm not saying your grandmother is a monkey! What I'm
saying is that to say, 'A dog will suddenly turn into a
cat,' is like saying 'You will turn into your cousin
overnight.' We both know that you will not turn into your
cousin overnight even though both of you share a
grandmother for a common ancestor, right?"
She: "Yes, but she's not a monkey!"
At that point I gave up, encouraged her to take a
university biology course, said "Good night," got into my
car, and drove home in a state of disbelief.
-=-
Return to The Skeptic Tank's main Index page.
The views and opinions stated within this web page are those of the
author or authors which wrote them and may not reflect the views and
opinions of the ISP or account user which hosts the web page. The
opinions may or may not be those of the Chairman of The Skeptic Tank.