American Civil Liberties Union Briefer ASK SYBIL LIBERTY Sybil says: SPEAK OUT! ORGANIZE!

Master Index Current Directory Index Go to SkepticTank Go to Human Rights activist Keith Henson Go to Scientology cult

Skeptic Tank!

American Civil Liberties Union Briefer ASK SYBIL LIBERTY Sybil says: SPEAK OUT! ORGANIZE! GET INVOLVED! We spend a big part of our life in school, so . . .let's make a difference -- * join the student government * attend school board meetings * petition the school administration * debate among yourselves ******************* YOUR RIGHT TO PRIVACY ******************* Students, listen up: An important part of our education is learning how to participate fully in the life of this nation. In order to participate, we need to keep in mind two very important things. First, the Constitution is the highest law of this land. Second, the Constitution has a Bill of Rights that protects the freedoms of each and every American. That includes you and me, the young people of this country. So my message to you is KNOW YOUR RIGHTS and EXERCISE YOUR RIGHTS. In a lot of our public schools, drugs and violence are serious problems that make it hard for teachers to teach, and for us to learn. Coming up with effective solutions to these problems is a tough assignment for even the best school administrators. Unfortunately, some school officials adopt "solutions" that abuse students' constitutional rights. For example, they search us, install video cameras in our classrooms, or plant undercover cops in the hallways and washrooms, to spy on us. Such measures treat us more like prisoners than students. Remember: The Fourth Amendment guarantees you a right to privacy and the right not to have your privacy invaded by "unreasonable searches and seizures." It also protects your freedom to make certain decisions about your body and your life in private, without interference from the government. ========================================================================= Sybil, what if I'm just hanging out in the hall and a teacher tells me to empty out my pockets. Do I have to do it? ========================================================================= SYBIL: Your teacher is supposed to follow the student search guidelines established by the United States Supreme Court in 1985, in a case called _New Jersey v. T.L.O_. The Court said that although school officials don't have to get a search warrant before searching you, your teacher or the principal can't search you without having a specific, good reason to suspect that you, in particular -- not just "someone" -- broke a law or a school rule. That principle is known as "individualized suspicion." AND... they must conduct the search in a "reasonable" way, based on your age and what they're looking for. For example, if a teacher thinks he saw you selling drugs to another student, he can stop you, pat you down, empty your pockets and search your knapsack or your car -- if it's parked on school grounds. ========================================================================== You mean teachers can't search every student in a class because they think some of us have drugs? ========================================================================== SYBIL: No, no and no. Just because school officials have information that *some* students have drugs doesn't give them the authority to search all students. ========================== What about a strip search? ========================== SYBIL: Strip searching of public school students by school officials is illegal in many states, and in others it's allowed but only under certain conditions -- like when there's a solid reason to suspect a particular student of having committed a *very* serious crime. ================================================================== What about the police -- can they search me on the school grounds? ================================================================== SYBIL: Yes, but police are held to an even higher standard than your teacher or principal: They have to go to court and get a search warrant from a judge. So if the cops want to search you, you tell them "no way" unless they either *arrest* you or show you a warrant. The warrant has to have your name or an accurate description of you on it, and it has to state what evidence the cops are looking for and where they think they're going to find it. ========================== Can my locker be searched? ========================== SYBIL: In some states, courts have ruled that your locker belongs to the school, not to you, so the school can search it. But courts in other states have said school officials must have "reasonable suspicion" that you're hiding something illegal before they can search your locker. Check with your local ACLU to find out what the law is in your state. And give yourself a break: Don't keep anything in your locker that you don't want other people to see. ============================================================================ Can my school make me take a blood or urine test to find out if I use drugs, or a breathalyzer test for alcohol? ============================================================================ SYBIL: A drug or alcohol test is a search, but it depends what state you live in whether the officials in your school have to have "reasonable suspicion" that you're a user before they can make you take a test. The ACLU has a problem with random testing programs, where officials test a few individuals or force a whole class to be tested just because they suspect that someone -- but nobody, in particular -- is doing drugs. Students all over the country have challenged such programs, but while the courts in some states have found them unconstitutional, they've said they're okay in others. Your local ACLU will give you the word on school drug testing in your state. ======================================================= Can my school use metal detectors to check for weapons? ======================================================= SYBIL: In many states, yes, because requiring someone to pass through a metal detector is regarded as less an invasion of privacy than are frisks or other kinds of searches. Still, some states recommend that school officials follow certain guidelines to protect students' rights. California, for example, allows metal detectors in its schools, but they can't be used selectively just on certain students. That would be discrimination. ============================================================================ Sybil, you said my right to privacy includes the freedom to make certain decisions about my body -- like deciding whether to have sex or have babies. Can you tell me where to go for a pregnancy test, medical care if I'm pregnant or an abortion? ============================================================================ SYBIL: You go to the nearest family planning clinic. If you can't find a clinic, call your local ACLU to get the name of one. Family planning clinics will give you birth control information, counseling and a pregnancy test, and some clinics also perform abortions and provide prenatal care. If the clinic you go to doesn't have one or more of the services you want, ask them to refer you to a place that does. =============================================================== Can I get birth control supplies without my parents being told? =============================================================== SYBIL: What you do or don't do with your body is nobody's business but yours. But you should be aware that although a doctor can legally write you a prescription for birth control, he or she doesn't have to. Also, a doctor has the choice of telling or not telling your parents, so you should ask what his or her policy is. Your school may provide birth control supplies. Check it out. ===================================================================== Would my parents and boyfriend have to be told if I decided to get an abortion? ===================================================================== SYBIL: First of all, it's your constitutional right to have an abortion -- be clear about that. *No* state requires you to seek your boyfriend's approval, but some states have laws that require young women under the age of 18 to get permission from their parents, or to tell their parents about the abortion. If you *can't* tell your parents, you may be able to go to court and ask the judge to drop the parental notification requirement in your particular case. Your local ACLU office can refer you to a family planning counselor who will help you. =========================================================================== Suppose I want to be tested for HIV, the virus that causes AIDS. Can I get tested without my parents knowing? Does *anyone* have to know? =========================================================================== SYBIL: Some states require that your parents be notified before you get tested or get treatment. Your local ACLU can inform you about how the laws in your state apply to HIV testing of minors, and where you can get tested without anyone knowing. By the way: If your school or employer is trying to *force* you to be tested for HIV, YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO REFUSE. Your local ACLU office can answer any questions you may have about your right to privacy in school and your other constitutional rights. To obtain a copy of _The Rights of Students_, a 181-page ACLU handbook, send name, address & check/money order for $6.95 to ACLU Dept. L, P.O. Box 794, Medford, NY 11763 A C L U Produced by the Public Education Department 132 West 43rd Street New York, N.Y. 10036


E-Mail Fredric L. Rice / The Skeptic Tank