TL: CHERNOBYL 8 YEARS AFTER - FACTS AND FIGURES SO: Greenpeace International, (GP) DT: March 31, 1994 (GP) Keywords: chernobyl ukraine republics nuclear power problems / Chernobyl 8 years After - Facts and Figures Since the accident at Chernobyl on April 26th 1986, Central and Eastern Europe have undergone momentous political changes. The authorities that oversaw the Chernobyl complex no longer exist, the unified fuel management system for the former Soviet Union has been disbanded, but the fallout from Chernobyl continues to kill and the reactors themselves continue to operate. With the political changes in the region in 1989, the wider world became aware of the true dangers of the reactors still operating in the former Soviet Union. Many statements were made and studies ordered, but little has changed for the better. In fact in most ways the situation is getting worse, on a daily basis. The time has come to call a halt to the backtracking on nuclear safety standards. In recent months we have seen: the International Atomic Energy Agency stress the safety of RBMKs; the intention of the Russians and Armenians nuclear industry to restart the Medzamor NPP; the Ukrainian authorities seeking to restart Chernobyl unit 2. It is clear that if this trend continues we will experience another accident, not in decades, but in years or even months. While considering this option it is important to study what are the true effects of such an accident. Contamination. The total area of land which are affected in Belarus, Ukraine and Russia is. Area Contamination Level (Caesium). Km2 kBq/m2 Ci/Km2 3 100 above 1 480 above 40 7 100 555 - 1 480 15 - 40 17 900 185 - 555 5 - 15 76 100 37 - 185 1 - 5 [1] Therefore the total area of land which is contaminated above 1 Ci/Km2 is 104 200 Km2. It is reported that nearly 5 million people live on this land. For comparison in the United Kingdom there are still approximately 600 farms which have restrictions placed upon them due to the Chernobyl accident. This is because the land which the sheep graze can causes the meat to be higher than the permitted intervention level (1,000 Bq/Kg). These areas are noted to have contamination levels at the time of the accident of between 20-25 kBq/m2.[2] Population Resettlement. The first population to be moved were from the town of Prypjat, where 49, 614 people resided. Over the following months an additional 90,784 people were evacuated from 75 villages in Ukraine. In Belarus, by the end of 1986, at estimated 25 000 people from 107 villages were also moved. In Russia, according to a decree issued by the Russian Federation's Council of Ministers on October 5, 1989, 4,725 people from 31 villages were designated as priority evacuation. Later an additional 13 villages with a population of 2,080 were added to the list. The total number of evacuated and resettled from 1986 to 1991 was 163 000. The evacuation plan required 218 900 people to move between 1990-2. However, by October 1991, only 121 000 had actually been moved. One of the goals of the 1991 plan was to resettle people living in regions contaminated above 40 ci/km. In 1992-3 it would have been necessary to resettle an additional 85 000 people. However, it is not clear as to whether or not the Ukrainian and Belarus governments had sufficient resources to carry this out. [3] Health Effects. The radiation and health debate is highly complex and often confusing. The extent to which the populations who live, eat and breath in contaminated areas will be effected is still not clear. However, one of the most indisputable effects is that of thyroid cancer in children in contaminated areas. In 1993, the World Health Organisation (WHO) published provisional findings from its Thyroid programme. They reported an up to 24 fold increase in Thyroid cancers in certain areas in the seven years following the accident as had previously been found in the same time period before the accident. [4] What makes this issue so important is the direct relationship of the Chernobyl accident to the increase in prevalence of the disease. However, the decree to which certain organisations, notably the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), have in the past sort to dismiss the prevalence of the thyroid cancers is extremely negligent and is obstructive to the development of further work in the region. In the 1991, "The International Chernobyl Project: An Overview: Assessment of Radiological Consequences and Evaluation of Protective Measures", published by the IAEA they reported "No abnormalities in either thyroid stimulating hormone or thyroid hormone were found in children examined. No statistically significant difference was found between surveyed contaminated and surveyed control settlements for any age group". It is not surprising that the decree to which even these figures are contested has been remarked on by WHO staff as an indicator of the difficulties which scientists face in trying to establish the real extent of the health problems. There are many other reported health effects, such as the following from a leading British newspaper. [5] Belarus : Breast cancer is on the increase; so are disorders of the blood circulation. Almost 2 million people in 3,331 town and villages need "special attention". The republic needs "clean" food, diagnostic equipment, radiation instruments and rehabilitation centres, and will need to spend $400-500 million between now {Nov 93} and 1995. Ukraine : 190 people have acute radiation sickness, 20,000 have lost their capacity to work; 1.5 million children whose thyroid glands received radiation doses. Only about 28% of the "liquidators" - more than 180 000 were involved in the clean-up - could be considered healthy. There are people with respiratory disease, hear troubles and nervous system disorders. There are increased digestive problems, tonsillitis, anaemia, and stress. There is an increase in suicide. There are children with "Chernobyl syndrome". Russia : 25% increase in tumours; of a 50% increase in cardiovascular disorders; of locomotor apparatus diseases. It is extremely difficult to understand the true nature of the health effects as a result of Chernobyl. However, clearly the Thyroid cancers are an indicator of far worse figures to come in the future decades. Equally problematic are the figures for the number of people who have died as a result of the accident. Official figures for those that have died range from 31 to 8 000, and prediction for those who will suffer early deaths from 40 000 to 500 000. [6] Economic Implications. The countries of Belarus, Russia and Ukraine already have severe economic problems. In addition to this they have to bear the burden of the financial and social problems associated with the catastrophe at Chernobyl. In Belarus 20 % of the country's income is absorbed in the mitigation of the effects of Chernobyl, while in Ukraine the figure is about 13%.[7], In 1993, President Kravchuk stated that the medical bill alone for victims of the Chernobyl accident would cost about US $55 billion.[8] The comprehensive study undertaken on the financial implications, by Yuri Korakin, estimates the cost through to the year 2000 at between 170-215 billion roubles (which at the time of the release of the report in 1990 equated to $283-358 billion). His study did not even address the question of medical needs. [9] The accident at Chernobyl happened in a relatively unpopulated area of the European continent, where the value of land and property is relatively low. The Federal Ministry of Economics has estimated that a worst case accident scenario if one the reactors in Germany could cost up to $US 6 800 billion.[10] In 1992, the then Energy and Infrastructure director at the World Bank, Anthony Churchill presented a paper to the World Energy Council in Madrid. The paper made simple calculations, based on the expected cost to shut-down and replace the most dangerous reactors in Central and Eastern Europe and equated it to $ per head of population across Europe as a whole. He calculates it will cost about $2-4 per person per year. His conclusion was, as an insurance policy, was this a price worth paying, against another nuclear disaster. [11] References. [1] FROM THE EXPERT CONCLUSION ON CHERNOBYL ACCIDENT: CAUSES AND EFFECTS./Edited by V.B. Nesterenko, D.S. Phirsova/ The International Environment Restoration and Safe Human's Existence Association. The Integrated Committee of Experts (MinskMoskvaKiev).Multiplier: 1993. [2] Chernobyl Revisited - Five years On - Zhores Medvedev, Nuclear Engineering International April 1991. [3] The Chernobyl Accident Revisited: Source Term Analysis and Reconstruction of Events during the Active Phase. Alexander Roman Sich, Submitted to the Department of Nuclear Engineering In partial fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy, at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, January 1994. [4] World Health Organisation, Press statement, Seven Years After, 23rd April 1993. [5] Guardian November 18th 1993. [6] official figure of 31 deaths - The Spectator, 17th April 1993. 8 000 actual deaths - Independent, 14th April 1991. 40 000 early deaths - British nuclear industry 1991. 500 000 early deaths - Professor John Goffman, International Herald Tribune, 11th September 1986. [7] Nuclear Engineering International, February 1994. [8] Financial Times, 1st February 1993. [9] Wall Street Journal Europe, 29th March 1990. [10] Nucleonics Week, November 26, 1992. [11] Paper Prepared for the Special Session on Nuclear Safety in Eastern Europe and the Commonwealth of Independent States, World Energy Council, 15th Congress, Madrid - September 22, 1992. Nuclear Safety -- The Need for an Insurance Policy, Anthony Churchill.