                          THE SCIENTIST
Status: RO
 
 
VOLUME 8, No:1                             JANUARY 10, 1994
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
 
===============================================================
Articles published in THE SCIENTIST reflect the views of their 
authors and not the official views of the publication,         
its editorial staff, or its ownership.                         
============================================================
 
    *** THE NEXT ISSUE OF THE SCIENTIST WILL APPEAR ON  ***
    ***                JANUARY 24, 1994                 ***
    ***                                                 ***
    *******************************************************
 
 
 
Subscription rates for the printed edition are:
 
In the United States: one year $58, two years $94
Canada              : one year $82, two years $142
All other foreign   : one year/air cargo $79, 
                      one year/ airmail $133
 
 
THE SCIENTIST 
(Page numbers correspond to printed edition of THE 
SCIENTIST)
 
FOR SEARCHING PURPOSES:  
AU   = author
TI   = title of article
TY   = type
PG   = page
NEXT = next article
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI :                      CONTENTS
PG : 3 
============================================================
 
 
ASSESSING THE CLIMATE FOR WOMEN: The Association for Women 
in Science is planning to conduct "site visits" to evaluate 
the work environment for women in United States academic 
science. The project is modeled after a similar initiative 
by two physics societies  
PAGE : 1
 
SCIENCE EDUCATION REPORT: Science educators are endorsing a 
report by a panel of an interagency advisory group that 
criticizes the government's planning, oversight, and 
evaluation of the many federal programs in science, 
mathematics, engineering, and technology education. These 
experts also support the report's recommendations for 
improved coordination and evaluation of these programs  
PAGE : 1
 
BIAS CHARGED: A federal science scholarship program that 
uses as its sole criterion the ACT exam in math has raised 
questions and charges about standardized tests' fairness, 
with one organization contending that the test is biased 
against women  
PAGE : 1
 
NEW LEADER AT THE FOREST SERVICE: Environmental researchers 
are applauding the appointment of wildlife biologist Jack 
Ward Thomas as director of the U.S. Forest Service, 
predicting that he will spearhead an ecosystem approach to 
forest management; meanwhile, represen- tatives of other 
forest interests are questioning the advancement of the 
lifelong Forest Service scientist on similar grounds  
PAGE : 3
 
BOWER WINNER: Isabella L. Karle, whose use of X-ray and 
electron diffraction pioneered new ways to study the three-
dimensional structure of molecules, has received the 1993 
Bower Award in Science  
PAGE : 4
 
`STRATEGIC' BASIC RESEARCH: In an extensive interview with 
The Scientist,.MDNM/ newly confirmed NSF director Neal Lane 
says he recognizes the challenge of supporting curiosity-
driven research in a political and social climate more 
inclined toward deriving the benefits of applied 
investigations; but he also points out the crucial role of 
basic science in bringing about those benefits  
PAGE : 11
 
COMMENTARY: The past year has seen its share of problems--
job depression, funding cuts, the SSC demise--for the 
science community, but as researchers look to 1994, they can 
take heart in several events of last year, such as the 
appointment of research-oriented directors at NIH and NSF 
and the momentum toward ending sex discrimination in 
science. As events, good and bad, unfold, The Scientist will 
be there to provide scientists with the information they 
need to adjust to and take advantage of them, promises 
Eugene Garfield  
PAGE : 12
 
DEFENSE INDUSTRY SCIENCE: With the Cold War now history, 
defense and aerospace industry giants are redirecting their 
research efforts. Their success, according to the newsletter 
Science Watch, may depend on their research capabilities, 
which the publication attempts to gauge by evaluating nine 
top firms' citation records  
PAGE : 15
 
HOT PAPERS: A plant biologist discusses his paper on 
signaling pathways in plant genes  
PAGE : 16
 
PROBING TECHNOLOGY: Commercially produced DNA probes have 
become standard in molecular biology, not only for basic 
research but also for more directed uses--in forensics, as 
diagnostics, and in epidemiology, for example  
PAGE : 17
 
SCIENTISTS ON BOARD: Those distinguished scientists who are 
invited to join corporate boards of directors have a rare 
opportunity to see the inner workings of a corporation, 
network with prominent businesspeople, and influence the 
research directions of these firms--and get paid handsomely 
for it. But with the benefits come certain responsibilities 
and potential pitfalls  
PAGE : 21
 
RESEARCHERS F. HERBERT BORMANN AND GENE E. LIKENS have been 
awarded the 1993 Tyler Prize for environmental achievement  
PAGE : 23
 
NOTEBOOK  
PAGE : 4
 
CARTOON  
PAGE : 4
 
LETTERS  
PAGE : 12
 
CROSSWORD  
PAGE : 13
 
DNA PROBE DIRECTORY  
PAGE : 18
 
OBITUARY  
PAGE : 23
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Experts Laud Call For Revamping U.S. Science Education 
      Programs
 
Report warns of inadequate oversight and ineffective 
planning and management of the growing number of federal 
initiatives
 
AU  : BARTON REPPERT
 
TY  : NEWS
 
PG  : 1
 
Science education specialists are endorsing a recently released 
report by a top-level advisory panel warning that, despite 
unprecedented government spending on science, mathematics, 
engineering, and technology (SMET) education, the United 
States "remains at risk of losing its competitive edge." The 
experts join the report's call for significantly revamped 
planning, coordination, and evaluation of the federal 
government's programs in these areas.
 
In compiling The Federal Investment in Science, Mathematics, 
Engineering, and Technology Education: Where Now? What Next? 
the 15-member panel, convened by the Federal Coordinating 
Council for Science, Engineering, and Technology (FCCSET), 
surveyed some 300 education programs sponsored by 13 federal 
departments and agencies. The initiatives the panel examined 
were identified as "core programs," or those relating 
directly to SMET education, and funded at a total cost of 
about $2.2 billion. Support for programs not targeted 
specifically to SMET education may be as much as $24 
billion, the panel estimates.
 
In the report to FCCSET--an interagency group now being 
superseded by a newly formed Cabinet- level National Science 
and Technology Council--the group concludes that this 
"potpourri of programs" has evolved "with too little overall 
planning  and  with  inadequate   evaluation.... The federal 
portfolio of core programs is unbalanced and lacks 
coherence."
 
The panel contends that "it is time for a new culture of 
interaction, communication, and coordination to be developed 
and sustained within and among all federal agencies in the 
area of education."
 
Shirley Malcom, head of the American Association for the 
Advancement of Science directorate for education and human 
resources, says she supports both the focus and the 
direction of the report's findings and recommendations: "I 
think the points that they make are absolutely on target. 
Their concerns about coordination and communication and 
collaboration . . . are absolutely the right ones. We have 
to be a lot more willing to look at ourselves and look at 
our programs in a very honest and forthright way."
 
Malcom, who did not serve on the FCCSET panel, adds that 
"we're not going to see a lot more money in the near term . 
the resources that are available."
 
Among the major conclusions and suggestions of the panel 
are:
 
* The core programs are "unbalanced and lack coherence" and 
require a "stronger management plan" that ensures that more 
SMET programs are aligned with national strategic plan 
goals; are coordinated across agencies; and promote equity.
 
* Current evaluations of these programs are "often 
inadequate" for improving programs, providing 
accountability, or deciding which ones to cut or retain. 
Programs should be "evaluated rigorously," with an eye 
toward meeting identified national needs.
 
* "Research should be directed toward what works best in 
particular educational settings, for particular diverse 
audiences, and in non-traditional settings such as adult 
education."
 
* More money should be allocated to promote awareness among 
teachers, students, and researchers of available federal 
programs in SMET education.
 
* A greater emphasis should be placed on teacher-preparation 
programs at all levels, including "the latest findings on 
how best to promote student learning."
 
At the news conference to release the study early last 
month, panel cochairman Karl S. Pister, chancellor of the 
University of California, Santa Cruz, noted that 10 years 
ago a U.S. Department of Education commission report, A 
Nation at Risk, was widely acclaimed and "jarred the 
national conscience."
 
"Unfortunately, much of what was called for in that 1983 
report remains unfinished," he said. "At the same time, the 
federal government's efforts in science, mathematics, 
engineering, and technology education are not sufficiently 
coordinated to reverse the tide of mediocrity and apathy."
 
Pister said the FCCSET panel's study marked the first time 
that the federal programs have been "examined as a whole in 
the light of independent scrutiny."
 
Of the current climate for action on such issues, Pister 
said: "I think it's too early to judge the current 
administration. But I see very positive signs." He added 
that formation of the new NSTC, to be chaired personally by 
President Bill Clinton, "is a telling symbol to me that the 
administration is taking science and technology education 
seriously."
 
Panel cochairwoman Mary Budd Rowe, a professor of science 
education at Stanford University, told reporters that the 
study found only about 20 percent of the 300 federally 
supported education programs have been evaluated for their 
effectiveness. "We're in a competitive, almost life-death 
kind of struggle with other countries. And I don't think we 
can afford to invest big amounts in programs that don't 
work," she said.
 
Inducing Cooperation
Panel member Ernest R. House, a professor of education at 
the University of Colorado, Boulder, says that even after 
working in the field of government educational policy for 20 
years, when he got a more detailed look at the various 
programs he found the overall situation "so bad that I was 
just appalled."
 
House says a key problem has been that interagency groups, 
such as FCCSET, up to now have lacked sufficient authority 
to effectively oversee the range of programs. Within the 
different departments and agencies, "bureaucrats are used to 
hunkering down. They've seen these things come and go many 
times, so they're used to just saying, `Well, we can sit 
this out.' ... So I think it will take some kind of pretty 
strong authority to induce them to cooperate with each 
other."
 
Such authority may be wielded by the newly created NSTC. The 
council, established under an executive order signed last 
November to coordinate science, space, and technology 
policies throughout the executive branch, will incorporate 
FCCSET's duties. According to an official at the White House 
Office of Science and Technology Policy, FCCSET is expected 
to officially go out of business this month when its 
activities are taken over by NSTC and eight R&D coordinating 
committees being formed under the council.
 
Earl Dowell, dean of the engineering school at Duke 
University in Durham, N.C., says he strongly supports the 
FCCSET panel's recommendation that more attention be paid to 
widely disseminating information about federal programs--
particularly the results of pilot or experimental efforts.
 
"I think there's a lot of independent experimentation, and 
that's probably good to a certain degree--but not if, 
indeed, we keep repeating the same experiment without being 
aware of what other people have tried," he says.
 
Dowell observes that "at the moment,  I'm afraid  that  in  
too  many cases the educational experiments--even when well 
done--tend to impact a single campus, or perhaps just a few 
campuses, and not the broader range of institutions."
 
As an example of an NSF-supported pilot program whose 
results deserve to be more widely disseminated, Dowell 
points to a program involving faculty-led "engineering 
education coalitions" designed to improve educational 
quality at various engineering schools. Each coalition 
generally involves seven or eight campuses.
 
`Selling' The Product
Echoing Dowell's sentiments, another member of the FCCSET 
panel, Wendell G. Mohling, former president of the 50,000-
member National Science Teachers Association, says the study 
shows that improved efforts are needed to provide useful 
information to schools, teachers, and students about various 
federally supported programs.
 
"Just as with anything else, if you've got a good product 
you still need to sell it," he says. "For any classroom 
teacher there are dozens of things that come through the 
mailbox or to the school. But to get it to the teacher, at 
the classroom level, is what is really the name of the game 
here--to publicize these programs."
 
Leonard Minsky, executive director of the National Coalition 
for Universities in the Public Interest, a Washington, D.C.-
based group, comments about the report: "Basically, I 
couldn't agree more  with  the  conclusions.... They're 
absolutely right about the lack of coordination, evaluation, 
and accountability."
 
He adds that "from our perspective, there's tremendous 
overlap, enormous  sloppiness  in  the  system.... And 
there's absolutely no way of getting any kind of 
accountability out of the system as it's now constructed."
 
At the news conference, Luther Williams, National Science 
Foundation assistant director for education and human 
resources and acting chairman of FCCSET's education 
committee, said he takes the report's findings "very 
seriously."
 
"We will take this valuable input to heart, and very 
carefully consider how best to respond," Williams said. "We 
know we need to make some changes, and here is some sound 
advice on how to start."
 
For the 1994 fiscal year, which began last October, NSF is 
slated to spend $569 million on science and engineering 
education programs--an increase of 17 percent from the year 
before.
 
Within NSF, further steps to more thoroughly evaluate 
educational programs and initiatives are expected to be 
mapped out by the foundation's office of research, 
evaluation, and dissemination, headed by Daryl E. Chubin, 
who recently moved to NSF from the congressional Office of 
Technology Assessment (P. Beck, The Scientist, Nov. 1, 1993, 
page 22).
 
 
Barton Reppert is a freelance science writer based in 
Gaithersburg, Md.
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  :  WHAT THE FCCSET PANEL FOUND
 
TY  :  NEWS
 
PG  : 10
 
 
Following are excerpts from the Federal Coordinating Council 
for Science, Engineering, and Technology expert panel's 
report on federal programs to support science, mathematics, 
engineering, and technology (SMET) education:
 
*  "The impact of current federal dollars in SMET education 
remains unclear. A potpourri of programs has evolved. 
Federal expenditures are being made with too little overall 
planning and inadequate evaluation."
 
* "Too many Americans know virtually nothing of the 
mathematical and scientific concepts and discourse (to say 
nothing of the technologies) that enrich contemporary 
culture, social experience, and economic progress."
 
* "It is the strong view of this panel ... that a basic 
change in the way in which federal agencies view their roles 
is needed. It is time for a new culture of interaction, 
communication, and coordination to be developed and 
sustained within and among all the agencies in the area of 
education."
 
* "The panel found that today's federal programs in SMET 
education continue to be burdened by a lack of coordination, 
a lack of evaluation, and a lack of accountability. The 
federal portfolio of investments in SMET education needs a 
comprehensive, coordinated management plan  to  provide  
balance  and  coherence across and within federal agencies, 
other levels of government, and all levels of SMET 
education."
 
* "Despite continued federal expenditure, the percentage of 
minority students studying SMET subjects (particularly at 
the graduate level) remains abysmally low. In engineering, 
the physical sciences, and mathematics, women are also 
significantly underrepresented .... Federally funded 
programs must actively and continually seek ways to improve 
participation and retention of underrepresented populations 
and to make SMET accessible to all citizens."
 
* "For a majority of federally funded SMET education 
programs, no evaluation information is available at all ... 
or no serious inquiry beyond anecdotal or self-reported data 
has been made. This disturbing lapse must be addressed 
immediately. The federal government cannot continue to spend 
large sums of money without knowing if its programs are 
accomplishing their established goals."
 
Source: The Federal Investment in Science, Mathematics, 
Engineering, and Technology Education: Where Now? What Next?
 
 
Copies of the report are available from the National Science 
Foundation, Attn: Joyce Taylor, Suite 855 (EHR/RED),  4201  
Wilson Blvd.,  Arlington,  Va. 22230.
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI   : Women Scientists' Group Launches Effort To Probe  The 
       Plight Of Female Researchers
 
Through campus `site visits,' AWIS will investigate the 
prevalence of gender bias in academia
 
 
AU   : BARBARA SPECTOR
 
TY   : NEWS
 
PG   : 1
 
 
The Association for Women in Science (AWIS) is planning an 
ambitious project to assess the climate for female 
researchers in academia--by visiting several United States 
colleges and universities and talking with the women 
themselves.
 
The effort will take AWIS representatives into several 
schools for "site visits," during which they will discuss 
women's concerns with faculty, administrators, and students, 
reporting their findings to school officials. AWIS will also 
collect samples of institutional policy statements and other 
documents that women scientists feel either help or deter 
their advancement, which will be evaluated for inclusion in 
an upcoming publication.
 
The Washington, D.C.-based organization will ultimately 
"develop a model program that offers workable options for 
enhancing the academic climate for women science faculty" 
for dissemination to schools that were not visited, 
according to a draft proposal for the project.
 
Through this program, AWIS is trying to grapple with the 
question of why "women don't seem to move up in academia as 
readily as men," says AWIS past president Ellen Weaver, a 
retired professor of plant physiology from San Jose State 
University. "Women are hired in good faith, but somewhere on 
the climb to tenure, they don't make it." A 1991 National 
Research Council study Women in Science and Engineering: 
Increasing Their Numbers in the 1990s, Washington, D.C., 
National Academy Press), for example, found that 66 percent 
of the women Ph.D.'s on science and engineering faculties 
either were not tenured or were not tenure-track, compared 
with 40 percent of their male counterparts.
 
"The time has come to not just collect more data about how 
poorly women do," says Weaver, a co-principal investigator 
(PI) on the project. "It's time to go in and find out what's 
happening.
 
"We've been concentrating on teaching the women what they need to 
know to succeed, but maybe there's something the institution can 
do to be more accommodating to women."
 
The AWIS effort is modeled on a program now being conducted under 
the sponsorship of the American Physical Society (APS) and the 
American Association of Physics Teachers (AAPT), both of College 
Park, Md., and funded by the National Science Foundation. In the 
physics project, groups of women physicists conduct day-long site 
visits to departments that have requested help in improving the 
climate for women. AWIS aims to expand the effort, spending a 
longer time at each institution and looking at all its science 
departments.
 
AWIS is currently soliciting funding for its project and expects 
to clarify the funding status in March; in the meantime, it has 
begun collecting policy documents from various schools on an ad 
hoc basis.
 
In the project's initial phase, expected to take a year and a 
half, the organization will visit one institution--probably a 
liberal arts college, according to Weaver--and make 
recommendations for changes. In the second phase, AWIS will 
expand its visits to six schools, including a major research 
university and a historically black institution, "looking for 
institutional differences as well as departmental differences," 
says AWIS executive director Catherine Didion, a co-PI on the 
project. The program's final phase involves the creation of 
"regional training centers," where academics will attend 
seminars, receive diversity training, and learn how to adapt such 
programs for their own schools. Materials and methods used in 
these centers will be developed from information gathered in the 
site visits.
 
Key to the success of the project--and a crucial component of the 
physics program after which it is modeled--is that site-visit 
teams go only to institutions that invite them, and where high-
level administrators communicate the importance of the visit to 
the faculty, AWIS officials say. "There has to be a commitment in 
order to get anywhere on these issues," says Didion. "This 
program only works if you have support from the top."
 
Didion acknowledges that the idea of a site visit may be daunting 
to some administrators--"none of us would want someone to come in 
and tell us, `This is what you could be doing better'"--but notes 
that the goal is to reach "the institutions that recognize that 
they want to change and that they need to change." And, indeed, 
there are male administrators at such schools who will welcome 
the visitors, Didion says. "Men know they have to be part of the 
solution" to the problem of an unfriendly climate for women, she 
says, "but they don't know how to go about it. There's not a 
recognition of what the barriers are and how to address them."
 
A Model Program
The experience of the women physicists, who have been conducting 
site visits since 1990, bears this out. In fact, says Judy Franz, 
a professor of physics at the University of Alabama, Huntsville, 
and a co-PI on the physics site-visit project, the effort was 
born out of a meeting of physics department heads--an 
overwhelmingly male group. "They passed a resolution that more 
should be done by them to encourage women and minorities to enter 
physics, and wanted help from APS and AAPT," she recalls.
 
"We can get as many invitations as we need" to conduct site 
visits, says Mildred Dresselhaus, Institute Professor of 
Electrical Engineering and Physics at the Massachusetts Institute 
of Technology and co-PI along with Franz. "Fifteen years ago, 
there were a lot of individuals who would consider [climate 
issues for women] a non-problem. Now they are in the minority." 
While the site-visit reports are addressed to a department 
chairman, the team tries to meet with the provost, the president, 
and other senior administrators when possible; chairmen may share 
the team's report with faculty, students, and administrators.
 
Only 3 percent of physics faculty in U.S. universities are women, 
according to APS's Committee on the Status of Women in Physics. 
At the undergraduate and graduate levels, women physics students 
are a small minority, as well. As a result, some problems women 
physics students face are less common in disciplines such as 
biology, in which the numbers of women are greater, says Bunny 
Clark, University Professor of physics at Ohio State University 
and a site-visit team member.
 
Clark says that male physicists' lack of experience with dealing 
with women professionally may contribute to what could be viewed 
as a sexist environment. "In some cases, [male physicists'] 
socialization is perhaps slower than it would be in a situation 
in which there were equal numbers of men and women," she says. 
 
"What we've found is less than we would hope for in the ideal 
world," says Dresselhaus.
 
Site-Visit Findings
One issue that has come up during site visits, for example, is 
the presence of posters in the lab or office depicting nude 
or semi-clad women, say site-visit team members. "Some 
people who have them up don't even realize that people would find 
them offensive," says Franz.
 
Another site-visit finding is that male teaching assistants (TAs) 
often "are not given any training" on how to behave at the front 
of a classroom, says Michelle Shinn, an associate professor of 
physics at Bryn Mawr College who has been on several site visits. 
"How they're going to treat their women students is just left to 
their upbringing." As a result, she says, often "women feel 
undervalued or patronized--as a woman, you become the recorder of 
data rather than the taker of data, or a male TA might say 
something demeaning or flirt with you."
 
In a department with few women, a sense of isolation can 
exacerbate cases such as these, women physicists say, leading to 
a tendency to take personally issues that others might consider 
trivial. "When a woman often never sees another woman during the 
day, they think it's them, not the situation," says Dresselhaus.
 
To help overcome such problems--or, at least, to bring them to 
the attention of an official who can do something about them--
site-visit teams have frequently recommended that a department 
chairman schedule regular meetings with women students. Several 
departments that have undergone site visits have implemented this 
suggestion already.
 
"They encouraged us to try to [establish] a smaller-depart- ment 
kind of feeling," says David Campbell, physics department head at 
the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. Campbell, who 
administers nearly 300 graduate students and 66 faculty members, 
says that as  a  result  of the November 1992 site visit, his 
department instituted a faculty-student mentoring program and 
revived a peer mentoring program that "had sort of 
sputtered."
 
In addition, says Campbell, after he received the site-visit 
report, he met with women students to discuss the findings, 
including the need "to make the department a slightly warmer 
place" and the high degree of stress caused by the physics 
qualifying exam. "Eighty-six percent of the students who take it 
twice pass it, but there is a rumor that half the students fail," 
says Campbell. "We're working on trying to debunk that."
 
The physicists emphasize that a number of the site-visit teams' 
suggestions, if implemented, should help men as well as women. 
"One thing we really learned is that many of these problems are 
not gender-specific," says Campbell.
 
While the chairmen may enthusiastically welcome the site 
visitors, not every faculty member agrees that such an exercise 
is a good idea. "There are some individuals at these departments 
who would rather see us disappear off the face of the Earth--and 
we hear about it," says Dresselhaus.
 
James Legg, physics chairman at Kansas State University, whose 
department was visited this past fall, said that the reaction of 
the 25 faculty members covered a "wide range of responses--`Why 
are you doing this?' being one of them--[ranging to] `Good; I'm 
glad that we're looking at this issue and taking it seriously.'"
 
The "defense mechanisms" manifested by the faculty who reacted 
negatively to the visit, Legg says, included questions such as 
"`Why, in a time of tight employment, are you concentrating on 
women?'" and "`Is it really true that women are being 
disadvantaged by the atmosphere that we have today?'"
 
Toh-Ming Lu, physics chairman at Rensselaer Polytechnic 
Institute, says he wanted to have his spring 1992 site visit "not 
because we have something really good to show, but to see how 
they can help us improve.
 
"We recognize that this is a key issue and should be dealt with," 
he says. "We also recognize that we are historically male-
dominated. We [didn't] expect a glowing report." His goals for 
the encounter, he says, were "to stimulate some discussion, to 
encourage us to talk about what other women scientists think 
about--bad or good; to let our students meet with other women 
physicists, which we always want to do; and to let our 
administration know about women's issues.
 
"Because we have been male-dominated for such a long time, we 
lost track of realistic women's science issues," he says. In such 
circumstances, "you don't have in your mind how the real world 
is, how difficult it is for women to study physics."
 
Creating Change
Didion says her organization decided to adopt the physics program 
because "we thought it meshed well with AWIS. Our strength is in 
trying to do intervention--to create change as a catalyst." 
Evaluations from those outside an institution can be advantageous 
in this respect, she says: "Sometimes external organizations can 
do it effectively, where internal organizations won't be heard."
 
The goal of the AWIS project is not to solve individual women's 
problems, Weaver emphasizes: "We're looking at factors," she 
says. "We're not going to pursue anyone's individual case."
 
One reason the physics program has been able to garner 
invitations from so many schools, site-visit team members and 
department members say, is that the teams are composed of senior, 
respected scientists; Dresselhaus, for example, is a member of 
the National Academy of Sciences. "When I put together a team, I 
try to get people from different areas of physics," says Franz. 
Usually, some faculty members [at the school being visited] would 
recognize at least one of our names."
 
Kansas State's Legg says that, for him, the benefits of the visit 
were obvious. "Is it better to remain ignorant about the problems 
that you may have?" he asks rhetorically. "To me, it's a win-win 
situation. If they come in and point out problems and give us 
ways to improve them, we've got ourselves a better department. 
One doesn't mind being criticized if you're going to profit from 
it."
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Scholarship Criterion Challenged; Critics Charge Sex 
      Discrimination
 
AU  : FRANKLIN HOKE
 
TY  : NEWS
 
PG  : 1
 
 
Charges of sexual bias in a $2.2 million federally funded 
undergraduate scholarship program have kindled debate among 
science educators and others about the use--and misuse--of 
standardized tests in gauging the abilities of future scientists. 
The scholarships were awarded solely on the basis of such a test.
 
According to a report by the National Center for Fair and Open 
Testing (FairTest) in Cambridge, Mass., male high school students 
won 75 percent of the 471 college scholarships awarded in 1993, 
the first year of the National Academy for Science, Space, and 
Technology (NASST) program in the United States Department of 
Education. This was so even though young women earn higher grades 
in science and math than young men in both high school and 
college, FairTest says.
 
The reason more men than women won, FairTest says, is that 
the award relied on scores earned on the math portion of the 
American College Testing (ACT) assessment exam, a test the 
organization says is biased against women. The exclusive use 
of a standardized test for awarding the scholarships--one 
for each congressional district--was mandated by the 
legislation creating NASST. NASST was established to support 
students who choose science and math majors in college; 
winners commit either to attend graduate school or to go to 
work in a related field, one year for each year of 
scholarship support.
 
"The real shame of this program," says Cinthia H. Schuman, 
executive director of FairTest, "is that, at a time when we 
should be encouraging young women to go into math and 
science, we're sending the wrong message that test scores 
are valued more than the actual demonstration of promise in 
these areas."
 
Defenders of the ACT and other standardized tests 
acknowledge that there is a difference between the scores of 
male and female students. They insist, however, that the 
bias revealed is not an indictment of the tests, but instead 
is an accurate reflection of discrimination in classrooms 
and in society.
 
"According to the National Science Foundation, 76 percent of 
our college graduates in engineering; mathematics; and 
physical, life, and computer science are males and 24 
percent are females," said Thomas Saterfiel, vice president 
of the research division at ACT, in a statement. "These 
percentages are just what we see in the awarding of the new 
NASST scholarships."
 
"There's bias," adds Kelley Hayden, a spokesman for ACT. 
"There's no doubt about it. But the bias is in the 
classroom--it's in the society, really. You still have 
reports about how teachers call on boys more than girls in 
classes, for example. So, it's just an extension of that."
 
Hayden also says the tests are designed to predict how 
students will perform in their freshman-year college 
courses. As such, he says, the ACT has a predictive validity 
of 95 percent for both males and females. The tests were 
never intended to be used as the sole criterion for such 
scholarship awards, he adds.
 
"Our test scores should not be used alone to make high-
stakes decisions," Hayden says. "They should be used in 
conjunction with other information, such as class grades, 
recommendations, and other work that the students do."
 
Most critics agree on this point, but some go further, 
saying that standardized tests simply are not a valid way to 
predict how students will perform in science careers.
 
"This test is a flawed indicator," Schuman says. "Not only 
is it biased against girls, it also does not reflect the 
kind of skills that we are looking for in students. It 
doesn't measure a student's ability to write or think 
creatively or do a science experiment."
 
FairTest has written to members of Congress who serve on the 
education committees, asking that the law be rewritten 
before any further funds are appropriated for NASST. 
Meanwhile, the Clinton administration, while praising the 
aim of encouraging students to pursue science and math 
careers, has moved to neutralize the program. Officials are 
supporting instead another effort with similar goals called 
the National Science Scholars program, authorized in 1990. 
Under that program, which provides for broader selection 
criteria, 861 students showing promise in science fields won 
undergraduate scholarships this year.
 
"Congress stipulated in the law [that created NASST] that 
the department select one scholar per congressional district 
based on national test scores," said David A. Longanecker, 
assistant secretary for postsecondary education, in a 
statement. "The department implemented the law as authorized 
by Congress. The National Science Scholars program, in 
existence for several years, requires at least one female 
winner per congressional district. For this reason, the 
Clinton administration supports the National Science 
Scholars program and has not requested any further funding 
for NASST."
 
Without funding for the current fiscal year, the NASST 
program has effectively ended, according to Stephanie 
Babyak, an Education Department spokeswoman. Even without 
the bias charges against NASST, she says, the programs are 
largely duplicative in purpose.
 
Locating The Bias
Critics of standardized tests say they are inherently biased 
against women, at least partly because they reward 
characteristics thought to be shared by more men than women.
 
"Nobody has ever come up with one single cause for the 
gender gap," says Schuman. "Rather, a number of issues have 
been pointed to, primarily dealing with the format of the 
test. Somehow, the emphasis on speed and guessing does not 
allow girls to display their real abilities."
 
In 1989, the Center for Women Policy Studies in Washington, 
D.C., published The SAT Gender Gap by Phyllis Rosser, a 
study that sought to document inequities in the SAT, 
administered by the New York-based College Board. According 
to Leslie R. Wolfe, executive director of the center, Rosser 
did an item analysis of one of the SAT tests and found that 
there were 24 questions on which either men or women did 
substantially better. Of those, 22 favored men, she says.
 
Rosser's study also directly contradicts test-makers' claims 
that the exams predict the success students will have in 
college, according to Wolfe.
 
"The only purpose [of the SAT and the ACT] is to predict 
first-year college grades," Wolfe says. "In both cases, they 
fail to do so for women. The SAT underpredicts women's 
first-year college grades. So, you have women who earn 
higher grades in their first year of college than their SAT 
scores would indicate."
 
She adds: "High school grades are still the best predictor 
of college success."
 
Test-makers counter that they have worked hard to eliminate 
bias and have been largely successful--although some 
residual inequity does remain. They say that the tests are 
based on the courses students take and mirror students' 
participation and success in those courses.
 
"The test is a curriculum-based test," says Hayden at ACT. 
"If you've had, for instance, algebra, you'll score in a 
certain range. But if you've had trigonometry, you'll score 
higher. And if you've had calculus, you'll score higher."
 
About 5 percent more boys than girls take those courses, 
Hayden says, and in a heavily math-based science like 
physics, for example, about 11 percent more boys enroll.
 
Hayden also makes the point that criticizing the ACT for 
rewarding speed and guessing cuts both ways.
 
"The English portion of the test requires you to move just 
as quickly as the math portion does, and it's all multiple 
choice, too," Hayden says. "But the girls do a lot better 
than the boys on that. Why? Because they know that stuff 
better."
 
Critics are unmollified by such arguments from test-makers.
"They have responded by blaming the victims and blaming the 
schools for low SAT scores on the part of women," says 
Wolfe. "However, we have shown that even those women with 
the highest grades, sitting in the same high-level math 
classes in high school with boys, and getting higher grades 
[than the boys], are still getting lower SAT scores."
 
"The problem with tests like the ACT and the SAT," says 
Schuman, "is that, even when you match for a student's 
socioeconomic background, their parents' educations, the 
courses taken, and the grades received, the gap between the 
sexes does not entirely close."
 
Some science educators are more willing to give credence to 
the test-makers' view.
 
"The testing services have gone out of their way to take 
gender and race out of the test-taking," says Paul Saltman, 
a professor of biology at the University of California, San 
Diego. "I assume that those tests were not designed with a 
gender bias.
 
"But what isn't unbiased," says Saltman, who has also been 
active in reforming science education in local school 
systems, "is the environment in which young women grow up in 
elementary and secondary schools with respect to how science 
is taught to them, how they perceive science, and how their 
peers respect girls who are going into science."
 
Saltman says the bias in the test does speak to cultural 
problems more than it does to test-design flaws.
 
"It tells me that it's not hip, if you're a girl, to be a 
scientist," he says. "It's easier to be a male nerd than a 
female nerd, if you want to look at it that way, in terms of 
the psychosocial values we place on these things.
 
"It's crazy to worry about whether you fix the exam," 
Saltman adds. "What has to be fixed is how we do science 
education."
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Environmental Scientists Hail New Forest Service Chief
 
AU  : KAREN YOUNG KREEGER
 
TY  : NEWS
 
PG  : 3
 
 
For the first time in its 88-year history, the United States 
Forest Service has a research scientist at its helm instead 
of an engineer, a forester, or a public administrator. 
Environmental researchers are applauding the appointment of 
Jack Ward Thomas, a wildlife biologist from Oregon, as a 
breath of fresh air for an agency in the midst of transition 
from the primarily timber commodity-based outlook of the 
past decade to an ecosystem-based approach. 
 
As the new chief, "Jack will be a strong advocate for the 
[Forest Service] to do a better job of integrating science 
into decisions and policy at the Washington level as well as 
activities on the ground," says Charles Philpot, a plant 
chemist and station director of the Pacific Northwest 
Research Station, the Forest Service (FS) research branch 
for Oregon, Washington, and Alaska. "I think we'll see a 
shift back to more technical capability on the management 
side and more opportunities on the research side to 
strengthen our science programs." 
 
Philpot says that this strengthening will primarily manifest 
itself in enabling FS researchers to conduct more basic 
science, rather than applied studies related to forest 
management. However, he adds, "We may be in a position to 
hire more scientists, but that's unlikely because of other 
constraints on the federal government. What we'll be doing a 
lot more of, I suspect, is hiring scientists through 
contracts, postdocs, and those kinds of opportunities."
 
Forest Research, the independent scientific arm of FS and 
one of its four divisions, is composed of roughly 700 
scientists who conduct research within eight regional 
stations and one forest products laboratory; it draws on a 
broad spectrum of disciplines, from economics to ecology. 
Its roster of scientists does not include researchers who 
conduct resource management and technology transfer work. 
The agency's research budget is roughly 12 percent of FS's 
1994 total appropriated budget.
 
Many of Thomas's research colleagues outside FS also view 
his appointment as a positive move for the agency. Gene 
Likens, an ecologist and director of the Institute of 
Ecosystem Studies in Millbrook, N.Y., remarks that this "is 
a wonderful opportunity for FS to take a new leadership 
role," especially by incorporating the concerns of 
environmental scientists into consideration of forest 
management issues.
 
Bernard Bormann, a plant physiologist with the Forest 
Service Pacific Northwest Research Station laboratory in 
Corvallis, Ore., adds that Thomas "can bring a new vision 
and develop a new mandate for FS in general, and his call 
for developing a new definition of conservation that will 
head us into the 21st century is an excellent approach."
 
Researchers also feel that Thomas's appointment will have 
positive implications for scientists outside FS. "I think 
we'll see his influence on Congress, for example, in 
influencing how politicians might look at political support 
for scientific programs....  I think he will be used as a 
resource for documenting why it's important for agencies in 
the federal government to have independent research arms," 
says Philpot.
 
In his new position for just over a month, Thomas explains 
his approach to the future of FS: "As a scientist, I will 
try to ensure that the best science available is brought to 
bear on our land-management decisions; but, on the other 
hand, I want to make it clear that, at least in my mind, 
science is not the overriding factor. Science merely 
provides guidance to decision-makers.... Ultimately some 
warm human being has to make the decision. These decisions 
encompass social values, economic demand, and budgeting and 
funding." 
 
Appointment Controversy
Although much of the research community has welcomed his 
appointment, Thomas has been directly involved in 
controversial plans for managing national forests. These 
planning documents advocate a compromise for protecting the 
threatened northern spotted owl and its old-growth forest 
ecosystems in the Pacific Northwest while reallocating and 
decreasing areas of the forests for timber harvest, which in 
turn directly affect timber-dependent communities. Last 
April, President Bill Clinton selected Thomas as leader of a 
team of scientists who would produce a plan for managing 
forest ecosystems.
 
Reactions from the timber community to his appointment as FS 
chief run from guarded to negative, concentrating on his 
involvement in forestry management issues and the method of 
his appointment. At the same time, conservation advocates 
are cheering the selection.
 
Mark Shaffer, vice president for resource planning and 
economics with the research division of the Wilderness 
Society, a national environmental advocacy group based in 
Washington, D.C., asserts that although "we may not fully 
agree on the dimensions of the proposed solution to the 
ancient forest issue in the Pacific Northwest, Jack Ward 
Thomas certainly provided credible leadership in both the 
scientific and policy fields ... the kind of leadership the 
FS really needs."
 
On the other hand, Chad Oliver, a silviculturist at the 
University of Washington's College of Forest Resources, who 
has reviewed forest plans that Thomas proposed, states that 
he "is worried that [Thomas] represents a rather extreme 
preservationist position, such as those that came out in the 
options that he gave" in the ancient forest plan.
 
William McKillop, a resource economist with the University 
of California, Berkeley, College of Natural Resources, who 
has also reviewed the Thomas plan, attributes his discontent 
with the appointment to the current administration, not 
Thomas the scientist, saying, "The issue doesn't concern 
Jack Ward Thomas's qualifications ... but rather the choice 
of the Clinton administration to require someone who does 
not have a timber connection."
 
Chris West, vice president of the Northwest Forestry 
Association, based in Portland, Ore., a timber trade 
association that includes biological scientists in its 
constituency, says, "The biggest issue to us is for the 
first time the chief has become a political appointee," 
referring to another criticism that has been voiced--that 
Thomas did not come up through the senior executive service, 
a group of high-level administrators from which the Office 
of Personnel Management can choose senior government 
executives. West  adds, "We respect Jack for his expertise 
as a wildlife biologist and we'll just have to see, in terms 
of [being] an administrator, how he does."
 
Ecosystem Management
Thomas sees one of his roles as FS head as that of a 
synthesizer of the interests of the many groups the Forest 
Service of the future must deal with. "We'll take a broader 
view of  things  than  we  have  in  the  past ... we will 
consider conditions over a much longer period ... forests 
and lands will be cared for in a way so that they'll be 
productive generation after generation," he says. This 
philosophy of thinking on a larger scale is called ecosystem 
management, a new direction for FS, and, according to 
Thomas, also "includes economics and the welfare of people 
who are part of that ecosystem."
 
But Jackie Lang, state coordinator for the Oregon Lands 
Coalition, a grass-roots organization representing the 
interests of communities based on timber, grazing, mining, 
and recreation economies, says, "We're not taking issue with 
the fact that science is a critical component in the 
decision-making process; however, we reject the idea that 
science  alone  is   the  decision-maker .... We don't need 
a scientist in charge of the FS; we need a public 
policymaker who understands the big picture."
 
Thomas's supporters assert, however, that he indeed has a 
solid grasp of the big picture. "One of the things we'll see 
from Jack is that he's not going to say that science is an 
end-all--he recognizes quite clearly that there are a lot of 
things besides science that influence policy and management, 
[and] that we have to account for all of them.... I think 
Jack Thomas will take the position that both healthy 
ecosystems and healthy economies are important ... and he'll 
give strong treatment to both," says Tom Hamilton, an 
economist and associate deputy chief for research at FS in 
Washington, D.C.
 
Thomas began his career with the Forest Service in 1966 in 
Morgantown, W.Va., where he studied forest-wildlife 
relationships. From there he worked in Amherst, Mass., in 
urban forestry and wildlife biology. Since 1974, he has been 
the chief research wildlife biologist and project leader of 
the Forestry and Range Sciences Laboratory, a part of the FS 
Pacific Northwest Research Station, in La Grande, Ore.
 
He received his Ph.D. in forestry from the University of 
Massachusetts and currently holds adjunct professorships at 
four universities. Thomas is author of about 275 
publications, primarily in the areas of large-game biology, 
wildlife habitat, northern spotted owl management, and land-
use planning.
 
 
Karen Young Kreeger is a freelance science writer based in 
Broomall, Pa.
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Naval Lab `Experimentalist' Honored With Bower Award
 
AU  : EDWARD R. SILVERMAN
 
TY  : NEWS
 
PG  : 4
 
Isabella L. Karle, who pioneered new ways to study the 
three-dimensional structure of molecules, making use of both 
X-ray and electron diffraction, has been selected to receive 
the 1993 Bower Award and Prize in Science.
 
The four-year-old award, which consists of a gold medal and 
a cash prize of $250,000, will be presented in April by 
Philadelphia's Franklin Institute Science Museum to honor 
outstanding work in the life or physical sciences.The 
international committee that chose the 72-year-old chemist, 
who becomes the first woman to win the award, said that 
Karle is being recognized for facilitating wide-ranging 
research in chemistry, biology, and medicine. Her specialty, 
three-dimensional molecular modeling--which relies on 
detailed X-ray structures to determine accuracy and 
parameters--has contributed to the discovery of new 
pharmaceutical agents for many diseases.
 
But Karle, a senior scientist at the Naval Research 
Laboratory (NRL) in Washington, D.C., stresses that it was 
her husband, Jerome, who developed theories about X-ray 
crystallography that she pursued. "I'm an experimentalist," 
she says.
 
She taught herself X-ray crystallography from textbooks and 
then developed techniques for studying crystals, which led 
to a greater understanding of their three-dimensional nature 
and the effect on physical and biological properties. 
 
"What she came up with is now being used by 
crystallographers throughout the world," says Drake 
Eggleston, an associate fellow at SmithKline Beecham in 
Philadelphia. "We used to have to spend an inordinate amount 
of time trying to understand structures. Now our 
understanding occurs faster."
 
Practical Applications
Karle earned her Ph.D. from the University of Michigan, Ann 
Arbor, in 1944, when she was 22 years old. At Michigan, she 
met her husband, also a Ph.D. student in chemistry. After 
graduation, both Karles worked in Chicago on the Manhattan 
Project and then returned to Ann Arbor. At the end of World 
War II, they went to Washington, where they landed jobs at 
the Naval Research Lab, which was willing to hire them both.
 
"The problem was that we were looking for academic jobs, and 
we couldn't get work in the same city," she says, citing as 
reasons universities' anti-nepotism policies, bias against 
women, and not enough research funding in smaller towns for 
both of them.
 
Her husband--now chief scientist at NRL's Laboratory for the 
Structure of Matter--began working on so-called direct 
methods for analyzing crystal structures. Along with a 
collaborator, Herbert A. Hauptman of the Medical Foundation 
of Buffalo, Jerome Karle received a Nobel Prize in chemistry 
in 1985 for contributions to crystallography.
 
In the 1950s, Isabella Karle sought practical applications 
for her husband's mathematical theories. In 1963, she 
introduced the "Symbolic Addition Procedure," which 
revolutionized the types and complexity of problems that can 
be solved by analyzing crystal structures.
 
"She kind of took a chance by being the first one to 
demonstrate belief in her husband's theory," says Eggleston. 
"Of course, there wasn't much to lose. But direct methods 
allow us to solve any structure these days."
 
In her own research, Isabella Karle has applied the 
techniques she developed to the study of a wide variety of 
substances. These include crystals distilled from frog venom 
that produces toxins--which block specific nerve impulses--
and the rearranged atomic bonds found in thymine, a 
component of DNA, when it is irradiated.
 
Today, Isabella Karle heads the X-ray diffraction section of 
NRL's Laboratory for the Structure of Matter. She has been a 
member of the National Academy of Sciences since 1978. She's 
also served as president of the American Crystallographic 
Association.
 
As for her plans for the prize money, she is rather demur. 
"There are many things to do with it," she says, hinting 
that she may give some portion of it away. "But I don't want 
to promise anything at this point."
 
Also selected to receive an award from the Franklin 
Institute in April is Robert W. Galvin, chairman of the 
executive committee at Motorola Inc. of Schaumburg, Ill., 
for his efforts to improve quality and achieve customer 
satisfaction while building Motorola into a world-class 
semiconductor company. The award to be given to Galvin, the 
Bower Award for Business Leadership, does not include a cash 
prize.
 
The Bower awards were established in 1989 as part of the 
Benjamin Franklin National Memorial Awards. They were made 
possible by a $7.5 million bequest from Henry Bower, a 
Philadelphia chemical manufacturer.
 
Edward R. Silverman is a freelance writer based in Millburn, 
N.J.
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
                          NOTEBOOK
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : The Big Apple Recognizes Science
 
TY  : NEWS (NOTEBOOK)
 
PG  : 4
 
 
The Mayor's Awards for Excellence in Science and Technology, 
organized and administered by the New York Academy of 
Sciences (NYAS), were presented last month by New York Mayor 
David N. Dinkins at Gracie Mansion, the mayor's abode. David 
D. Ho, director of the Aaron Diamond AIDS Research Center 
for the City of New York at New York University School of 
Medicine, was honored in the field of biological and medical 
sciences for his "fundamental research" on HIV-1 and AIDS. 
Ho first identified the AIDS virus in the central nervous 
systems of patients with AIDS dementia, and his ongoing 
research and the reputation of the center has attracted 
"scores of scientists from all over the world," according to 
NYAS. In the category of technology, Stanley Baron, managing 
director of the Manhattan-based National Broadcasting Co., 
received a Mayor's Award for his technical and 
standardization contributions to digital television image 
processing, graphics, and automation of tape library record 
and playback systems. Leslie E. Robertson, senior partner in 
New York-based Leslie E. Robertson Associates and the 
designer of three of the world's tallest buildings--the twin 
towers of the World Trade Center in New York and the tallest 
building in Asia, the Bank of China in Hong Kong--received 
the award for "innovative structural engineering designs 
that have advanced worldwide designs and practices." He was 
also honored for having "nurtured the careers of many young 
engineers."
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  :  Energetic Endeavor
 
TY  :  NEWS (NOTEBOOK)
 
PG  : 4
 
For its 12th annual Duracell/National Science Teachers 
Association Scholarship Competition, the sponsoring battery-
maker has increased the number of winners and the method of 
rewarding the 9th- through 12th-graders whose battery-
powered inventions will garner one of the 100 prizes to be 
awarded. The competition will now grant United States 
savings bonds to the winners, with one first-place winner 
receiving a $20,000 bond, five second-place finishers 
netting $10,000 bonds each, 10 third-place winners garnering 
$1,000 bonds, 25 fourth-place winners receiving $200 bonds, 
and $100 bonds for each of 59 fifth-place finishers. In 
addition, every student to submit a complete entry will 
receive a wallet, and the teachers of the top 100 finalists 
will also get gifts, with an IBM PSI computer system going 
to the sponsoring teachers of the top six finishers. To 
enter, students must design and build a battery-powered 
device (using Duracell batteries) that is educational, 
useful, and/or entertaining, and submit a written 
description, a wiring diagram, and a photo of the device by 
January 21. For information, contact the Duracell/NSTA 
Scholarship Competition, 1840 Wilson Blvd., Arlington, Va. 
22201-3000; (703) 243-7100.
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Postdocs In Government Labs
 
TY  : NEWS (NOTEBOOK)
 
PG  : 4
 
The National Research Council has announced its 1994 
Resident, Cooperative, and Postdoctoral Research Associates 
Programs, which provide opportunities for Ph.D. scientists 
and engineers to pursue their research in 140 participating 
federal agency and research institution laboratories 
throughout the United States. Roughly 350 new full-time 
associateships will be awarded on a competitive basis in the 
areas of chemistry; earth and atmospheric sciences; 
engineering and applied sciences; biological, health, and 
behavioral sciences and biotechnology; mathematics; space 
and planetary sciences; and physics. The awards are made for 
one or two years, and are renewable to a maximum of three 
years, with stipends averaging $35,000 to $45,000 annually, 
plus some relocation and travel expenses. Applications are 
accepted throughout the year; deadlines for consideration in 
1994 are January 15, April 15, and August 15. For 
information, contact Associateship Programs (TJ 2094/D2), 
National Research Council, 2101 Constitution Ave., N.W., 
Washington, D.C. 20418; (202) 334-2760. Fax: (202) 334-2759.
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Teaching Teachers About The Sea
 
TY  : NEWS (NOTEBOOK)
 
PG  : 4
 
A $1 million grant from the National Science Foundation, 
coupled with an $80,000 contribution from the Pew Charitable 
Trusts of Philadelphia, will enable the Sea Education 
Association (SEA) to greatly expand its SEA Experience 
summer research and education program for science teachers. 
The five-week SEA Experience program gives teachers an 
opportunity to learn about oceanography, collaborate with 
ocean scientists and mariners, and apply their experiences 
to develop an ocean-based classroom curriculum. Teachers 
pursue intensive on-shore studies in oceanography and 
nautical science on SEA's Woods Hole, Mass., campus, and 
then live and work aboard SEA's two research ships 
conducting investigations in the North Atlantic. The grants 
will enable the nonprofit educational organization to double 
the number of teachers participating in the program, include 
elementary schoolteachers, and pay for educational 
consultants to assist in creating an enhanced program. For 
information, contact SEA, P.O. Box 6, Woods Hole, Mass.; 
(508) 540-3954. Fax: (508) 457-4673.
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : New NAS Publishing Outlet
 
TY  : NEWS (NOTEBOOK)
 
PG  : 4
 
The National Academy Press, publisher of studies conducted 
by the National Academy of Sciences, the National Academy of 
Engineering, the Institute of Medicine, and the National 
Research Council, has announced the creation of a new 
publishing branch. Joseph Henry Press, named after NAS's 
second president and a prominent early American scientist, 
will acquire and publish books on a broad range of science 
topics for a wider audience, including young scientists and 
interested lay readers. The new publishing arm is actively 
seeking manuscripts and book proposals. For information, 
contact Joseph Henry Press, 2101 Constitution Ave., N.W., 
Washington, D.C. 20418;  (202) 334-3180.  Fax:  (202) 334-
2793. Internet: bkline@nas.edu.
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Scientists In Congress
 
TY  : NEWS (NOTEBOOK)
 
PG  : 4
 
Applications are now being accepted for 1994-95 American 
Institute of Physics and American Physical Society 
Congressional Science Fellowships, in which Ph.D. scientists 
spend a year as legislative assistants to members of 
Congress or committees, providing their expertise in 
consideration of science-based issues while also gaining 
insight into the political process. The AIP/APS program is 
one of 20 professional society programs of this sort 
organized under the auspices of the American Association for 
the Advancement of Science since 1988. According to AAAS, 
several fellows have remained on in prominent positions in 
government. Qualifications include a Ph.D. in physics, U.S. 
citizenship, and membership in an AIP member society. 
Application materials are due January 15. For information, 
contact Audrey T. Leath at AIP, (301) 209-3094.
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
                          OPINION
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : NSF's Neal Lane: In Pursuit Of `Strategic Basic Research'
 
AU  : FRANKLIN HOKE
 
TY  : OPINION
 
PG  : 11
 
 
-----
Editor's Note: As Neal Lane settles into his new job as 
director of the National Science Foundation, his enthusiasm 
is tempered by a clear understanding of the formidable 
challenges facing him, his agency, and the United States 
research community in general.
 
While confident that the nation can maintain its scientific 
leadership internationally, the 55-year-old physicist and 
former Rice University provost acknowledges that, if 
American science is to fulfill its mission, it must do so in 
the context of a rapidly changing global environment, with 
all countries seeking to reshape and reidentify themselves 
in the post-Cold War world.
 
Foremost among NSF's objectives, Lane contends, is the 
identification and support of scientific endeavors that 
accommodate both the individual investigator's inclination 
to pursue pure research and the nation's need for 
applications of scientific discovery. Such applications 
could come, for example, in the form of advanced technology 
and commercial products that shore up America's commanding 
position in the increasingly competitive world economy.
 
In discussing agency goals in this regard, Lane uses the 
phrase "strategic basic research"--an idea that may well 
serve him in his efforts to balance pressures from Congress 
for NSF to do more immediately useful work against the 
urgings of supporters of basic, curiosity-driven, untargeted 
investigations.
 
In a recent exclusive interview with Senior Editor Franklin 
Hoke--conducted shortly after Lane was confirmed by the U.S. 
Senate as NSF director--he expressed his views on the 
direction that, if he has his way, the agency is likely to 
take in the near future. Following is an edited presentation 
of that interview.
----
 
Q  Dependable year-to-year federal funding support is, of course, 
vital to basic research and other efforts--programs in science 
education, for instance. As you look at 1994, do you foresee any 
areas where maintaining current NSF support levels may be 
especially difficult for you?
 
A  Continuity of support is certainly important to individual 
scientists and engineers and also to the programs. But because of 
fluctuations in the annual federal appropriation, it's sometimes 
a challenge to provide that continuity. Large construction 
projects, for example, have to be planned well in advance, and 
they have to be funded adequately on an annual basis. Otherwise, 
they get stretched out, and the overall cost goes up. In a bad 
year they can really squeeze the research budgets. You try to 
resist that. But it is a balancing act.
 
Q  What are some of the large projects that you feel must  move 
forward, even if their high expense would necessitate cuts in 
other areas of the NSF budget?
 
A  The one that looms large right now is the LIGO [Laser 
Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory] project. That 
project is very good science, the timing is right to go forward, 
and it's a fully approved project--it's just a matter of getting 
the money. I might also mention the FCCSET [Federal Coordinating 
Council for Science, Engineering, and Technology] initiatives--
the federal strategic initiatives where the foundation enters 
into interagency agreements. These are the things like high-
performance computing and communications, advanced-manufacturing 
technology, and advanced-materials processing. We try to meet 
those interagency agreements, of course, and in a tight budget 
year, that could cause other research that does not happen to fit 
within one or another of the strategic definitions of the 
initiatives to get squeezed.
 
Q  Regarding priorities, are there any programs for which you 
would hope to find more support?
 
A  The area of education and human resources--along with the 
FCCSET initiatives I've mentioned--is clearly a high priority for 
the country and an area of emphasis for NSF. By continuing to 
emphasize these initiatives, we really are doing something that 
is very important for the science, engineering, and technical 
foundations of the country. I include the national information 
infrastructure initiative because high-performance computing and 
communications really provide the technical foundation for a much 
larger initiative that seeks to bring technology to all aspects 
of people's lives--education, health care, and every area in 
which information and the rapid transmission of it can be helpful 
to the country.
 
Q  Your agency increasingly has become involved in fostering 
technology transfer between academia and industry as a means of 
strengthening the United States economy. What kind of priority do 
you expect to give to technology transfer and related issues of 
economic competitiveness? 
 
A  Projects that academic researchers work on deal with some very 
fundamental or, we sometimes say, foundational questions. These 
people are involved in making discoveries about the way nature 
works, and many NSF researchers, by working with industry 
directly and by educating students who go on to work in industry, 
transfer new technologies and knowledge to a whole wealth of 
applications, frequently industrial applications. New knowledge 
is the goal, and new technology has often come out of the 
research process, particularly in the experimental pursuit of new 
knowledge. That's why the connections between industry and the 
universities are so important. I believe that the only way that 
technology really gets transferred is through close interaction 
between people. These interactions with industry are very 
important for both the universities and the industry.
 
Now, I think it would be a mistake if we were to change the 
objectives of NSF programs so that they were narrowly focused on 
producing new technologies and transferring them to industry. 
That's not what most university researchers are good at, and 
industry knows that. Industry doesn't want to see that kind of 
change in the NSF mission; I really don't believe anyone does.
 
Q  But pressure to do more targeted research that will meet 
national needs has been growing. What's your view of the pressure 
being applied by Sen. Barbara Mikulski [D-Md.] and others in this 
regard?
 
A  Over half of the research that NSF supports is strategic or 
targeted research, that is, research in fields that have been 
identified as being directly relevant to some of the nation's 
highest-priority needs. However, the research that is supported 
in these areas is very fundamental, and it meets the high 
standards of review that NSF requires. Now we are being asked to 
see if we can't fund more basic research in strategic areas, and 
that request certainly is entirely understandable and not 
unreasonable. I don't believe we're really being asked to perform 
applied research.
 
Q  You are not, then, anticipating a dramatic change in direction 
for your agency?
 
A  The nation has serious problems. All of us should contribute 
to their solution in whatever ways we can. The question is, can 
NSF do more of that, and I don't know the answer. Perhaps it can. 
It's a question of balance. If we can support more strategic 
basic research without lowering the standards of merit that have 
long characterized the success of the foundation and the 
community it supports, then there's no law that I'm aware of that 
says exactly what fraction of strategic research it is 
appropriate to fund.
 
Q  Much has been said about changes in our national science and 
technology goals since the end of the Cold War. NSF is not a 
Department of Energy entity, of course, but what effect do you 
think the changes on the international scene are having, or will 
have, on NSF?
 
A  The strategic initiatives I mentioned earlier are based on 
this change in the world. Some of the initiatives have directly 
to do with the competitiveness of our country in the global 
market, and some of them--those pertaining to the environment, 
for example--have to do with the quality of life of U.S. citizens 
and other people in the world. The research community will 
continue to be asked to provide the underpinnings of the 
knowledge base and technology that are important in these various 
areas of application. And I expect the research community will be 
responsive.
 
Q  How do you regard the notion that this responsiveness, in 
terms of practical applications, may compromise or dilute basic, 
so-called curiosity-driven research?
 
A  Our scientists, engineers, and educators understand that the 
reason the federal government funds their research activities is 
because the results of such research are expected to be of value 
to the people. What drives them individually is the fundamental 
curiosity about how nature works, the opportunity to work with 
bright and interesting young people in the universities, and so 
forth. But I think researchers entirely understand that the 
expectation is that the results of their work are for the good of 
humankind. Sometimes, it is hard to predict exactly in what time 
frame these results will pay off, but it is expected that 
ultimately they will be valuable.
 
Q  The National Academy of Sciences' COSEPUP [Committee on 
Science, Engineering, and Public Policy] issued a report last 
year [Science, Technology, and the Federal Government: National 
Goals for a New Era, Washington, D.C., National Academy Press, 
1993] suggesting, that we should fund selected research areas in 
which the U.S. can establish clear global leadership. Do you find 
this policy framework a useful one?
 
A  We have an international effort here at the foundation and 
have had for some time, and I think that international concerns 
are going to be as important, if not more important, in the 
future than they have been in the past. It is very important that 
we maintain good, close interactions between our scientists and 
engineers and those in other countries, and exchange ideas and 
knowledge. We will be the beneficiary of that kind of openness, 
so that's pretty high on my agenda.
The foundation and the science community have long considered 
international comparison as one metric for assessing where a 
field is at a particular time. There are good reasons for that: 
Even if you aren't the world leader in a particular field of 
science, unless you have some of the best scientists working in 
that area, and you are making discoveries, you really can't take 
advantage of discoveries in that field that are made elsewhere. 
You must have your people interacting with people in other 
countries, working right at the edge of the field, so that as a 
discovery is made someplace else it can be picked up here. 
Sometimes those discoveries, as I pointed out earlier, are of 
immediate importance to one or another application, and the way 
to make sure that that application can occur is to be sure that 
we have people working right at the cutting edge of that same 
area of science.
 
Q  No matter what skills a leader brings to his or her job, there 
are limits to what can actually be accomplished. Limiting factors 
can include budgetary constraints, institutional inertia, and 
policy opposition. Do you anticipate these kinds of broader 
impedi- ments in any particular areas that you'd like to succeed 
in? 
 
A  Realistically, budgets are a constraint. We always have many 
more good ideas out there than we can support. That's been true 
for a very long time at NSF, so you always feel somewhat 
constrained. We set our priorities, and we evaluate programs, and 
we believe that we allocate the funds in a way that is in the 
best interest of the country in support of science and 
engineering. But there are many opportunities that we're really 
not able to follow up on just because the funds are limited.
 
Q  Do you expect to see any relief from budgetary constraints in 
the near future?
 
A  The nation is having tough times. The economy remains a great 
concern, and the efforts to control the budget deficit are 
serious and important. So we recognize that there are not likely 
to be large increases in many budgets over the next several 
years. But I think there is strong support for NSF, I think there 
is strong support for the community of scientists and engineers 
that we fund, and I think there are great opportunities here for 
the future of these fields.
 
Q  Do you need anything from the community of scientists and 
engineers in support of what you want to do? Do you need them to 
do something for you?
 
 
A  It is very important that scientists and engineers realize why 
the tax dollars of the public are used to support research and 
education. I also think that as the mission agencies begin to 
develop their programs in support of national needs, it will be 
important for the researchers to be responsive. We have many 
scientists and engineers out there whose interests could be much 
broader, perhaps, than they have been in recent years. There are 
real opportunities for those who want to pursue somewhat 
different areas of research. So, it would be very helpful if our 
colleagues in the universities and colleges would open their 
minds to some of these larger questions that society is asking 
and that the federal government is trying to address, to see if 
there are ways that they can be helpful as individuals or 
collectively.
 
Q  Looking ahead, what are your expectations for science in the 
U.S.? What do you see in your crystal ball?
 
A  Well, I certainly don't have a crystal ball, but I'm 
optimistic about the future of the country and of science, 
engineering, and technology in particular. And I base that 
optimism on the fact that we do have the finest system of higher 
education in the world. We're being very aggressive in addressing 
some problems we feel we have in K-12 education. We have a very 
strong science and engineering infrastructure in place: the 
laboratories, the people, and the educational process. Industry 
is reaching out to universities, and universities are responding. 
There are examples of partnerships between government and 
industry, between different federal agencies, and between federal 
and state governments.
 
In other words, teams are forming, and whenever Americans form a 
team, history tells us, they are very hard to beat. So, I feel 
quite positive about the future. I expect that we're actually 
going to solve  some  of  these  major  problems.
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
                         COMMENTARY
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : There Are Reasons For Optimism As We Launch The New Year
 
AU  : Eugene Garfield
 
TY  : OPINION (COMMENTARY)
 
PG  : 12
 
Although the United States research community had its share 
of problems during 1993--a depressed job market, 
congressional budget cutting, the demise of the 
superconducting supercollider, and so forth--it was a banner 
year in many respects, as well, yielding abundant cause for 
us to be optimistic as we enter the new year.
 
Our hopes should by buoyed, for instance, by the knowledge 
that the National Institutes of Health is now led by Harold 
Varmus, a distinguished biologist. Varmus appears eager to 
defend the clear merits of basic biomedical investigation 
and to voice the demand, on behalf of the nation's bench 
scientists, for the financial--and philosophical--support 
that curiosity-driven research clearly deserves.
 
Not unrelated is the sense of confidence we can gain from 
the recent appointment of Neal Lane as director of the 
National Science Foundation. On page 11 of this issue, we 
present an exclusive interview with Lane, who also appears 
to understand the value of untargeted research. Lane, of 
course, will have his hands full in his efforts to 
accommodate the interests of pure research while under 
pressure from powerful figures in government and industry 
who insist that federally supported science must have a 
practical, fiscal, near-term--if not immediate--payoff.
 
Also most gratifying during the past year was the momentum 
achieved by those organizations and individuals dedicated to 
the eradication of sexual harassment from the scientific 
workplace and the fair treatment of women researchers. The 
articles on the front page of the current issue underscore 
the progress that's being made regarding these concerns; the 
elaborate projects under way at the Association for Women in 
Science and other organizations, along with evidence of a 
rising consciousness throughout the science community, are 
indeed heartening.
 
Looking back over The Scientist's coverage during 1993, I 
remain particularly encouraged by a front-page photo we ran 
in our October 18 issue: It  pictured  Hillary Rodham 
Clinton gazing admiringly at Mary Lasker, a long-time 
supporter of basic research; the captured moment signaled to 
me that the interests of the nation's individual 
investigators have an appropriately high position on the 
Clinton agenda.
 
The interests of biomedical scientists are of vital concern 
to me, as publisher, since the overwhelming percentage of 
our 50,000-plus readers are NIH grantees--among them more 
than 90 percent of the members of the Federation of American 
Societies for Experimental Biology and of the American 
Federation for Clinical Research. Members of these two 
groups alone account for a huge percentage of NIH extramural 
grants, not to mention grants from such private foundations 
as the Howard Hughes Medical Institute. While a significant, 
and increasing, number of our readers are industry-supported 
researchers, it should be clear that the prospects for The 
Scientist's continuing success are closely intertwined with 
the professional prospects of our academic readership, as 
well,  and their success in securing NIH's support.
 
Repeated studies give me good reason to believe that The 
Scientist plays a unique role as a vital news and opinion 
source for America's scientific community. While we all 
suffer from information overload, our readers tell us that 
they find our publication both useful and enjoyable. In 
1994, we'll continue our in-depth coverage of major news 
events, employment-related issues, research breakthroughs 
and emerging patterns, and the latest innovations in 
laboratory tools and technology. And we'll continue 
presenting incisive opinions and commentaries by and about 
the men and women who are shaping the science community.
 
Many uncertainties face us all as we enter the new year. We 
can only hope, for instance, that the sluggish U.S. economy 
will regain energy; we can only hope that President 
Clinton's health care reform and free-trade programs will 
materialize as beneficial for both science and society; and 
we can only hope that Congress will play a proper role in 
supporting the nation's research activities.
 
As the year progresses, The Scientist's readers can depend 
on us to keep them up to date on these and other crucially 
important matters. At the same time, we at The Scientist 
will depend on our readers to keep us up to date on their 
personal views concerning the issues of the day as well as 
their reactions to our publication.
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
                          LETTERS
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Integrated Education
 
AU  : J.D. ANDRADE
 
TY  : OPINION (LETTERS)
 
PG  : 12
 
I enjoyed your Opinion page in the Oct. 18, 1993, issue, 
written by six students from the University of Miami [R. 
Andreasen, et al., page 11]. Their perspective, their 
diagnosis, and their recommen- dation for treatment of high 
school education is insightful and, from my experience, most 
appropriate. Our own small effort, the Center for Integrated 
Science Education at the University of Utah, is focused on 
applying most of their recommendations at the elemen- tary 
and junior high level. We have found that the teachers and 
the public education community in general are very 
responsive to our initiatives and generally want to enhance 
the educational experience for their students.
 
A major part of the problem in major research universities 
is the way science is taught. At our institution, we are so 
stringently organized along departmental lines that only the 
most interdisciplinary individuals have an interest in 
looking at science in a more integrated fashion--in relating 
their expertise to other courses and other subjects. "Cold 
fusion" could have originated only in a university where 
physicists and chemists rarely communicate. There are very 
few institutional incentives to facilitate interdisciplinary 
communication.
 
It is therefore difficult for a high school teacher who 
obtains his or her credentials from such an institution to 
effectively involve students or to integrate science in the 
high school environment.
 
None of this will substantially change until department 
chairpersons, deans, vice presidents, and presidents of 
major research institutions do more than give lip service to 
these problems. Until that happens, only a small fraction of 
the faculty will have the commitment, the foresight, and the 
uncommon sense to involve their students in science in the 
manner so eloquently presented by those six Miami 
undergraduates.
 
 
J.D. ANDRADE
Center for Integrated Science Education
University of Utah
Salt Lake City, Utah 84112
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Gel Scanners
 
AU  : GREGG HOFF
 
TY  : OPINION (LETTERS)
 
PG  : 12
 
I disagree with the evaluation of gel scanner systems in the 
Oct. 4, 1993, issue of The Scientist [C.D. Potter, page 18]. 
The article states that gel scanners are "expensive" when 
compared to gel documentation systems. This statement is 
potentially misleading.
 
The article does not distinguish between gel documentation 
systems, which primarily perform one function, and gel 
scanners, which may perform a wide range of functions, 
including analysis, databasing, and documentation.
 
Dedicated gel documentation systems may be the best choice 
for labs that need only documentation. But for labs that 
need documentation and analysis, a gel scanner system with 
documentation capabilities may be a cost-effective option.
 
If you wanted to focus on only one type of system, you 
should have either omitted reference to gel scanners or 
explained how the systems are used for other applications. 
Dismissing the systems as merely "expensive" is a disservice 
to readers.
 
 
GREG HOFF
Millipore Corp.
80 Ashby Rd.
Bedford, Mass. 01730-9125
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Fetal Tissue Ethics
 
AU  : ROLAND F. HIRSCH
 
TY  : OPINION (LETTERS)
 
PG  : 12
 
I read the article on fetal tissue research in your October 
4 issue [M.E. Watanabe, page 1] with interest. However, it 
is not a balanced picture of this topic. Reputable medical 
researchers have expressed doubts about the potential 
utility of fetal-tissue transplants. The article should have 
included these viewpoints.
 
The more serious flaw in the presentation was its lack of 
consideration of ethical issues. The moratorium referred to 
in the article was on research with tissue from induced 
abortions, not on all research in this field. There are 
legitimate concerns that clinical use of fetal tissue for 
transplants will in many cases require scheduled (not 
elective) abortions. Indeed, it is difficult to imagine a 
brain surgery team waiting for an abortion to just happen so 
that the tissue is available for their use. The scheduling 
problem will lead to women being recruited and paid to have 
abortions. What controls could prevent this, considering the 
frequency with which existing regulations, such as on late-
term abortions, are violated?
 
A related concern is that some proposed transplantation 
procedures would require tissue from babies late in 
pregnancy, often in the range at which they could live if 
born. Should young lives be sacrificed to potentially help 
older people?
 
I do not believe that medical researchers should blindly go 
ahead to develop procedures that could violate the standards 
that make us civilized. The author should have offered 
references for readers interested in the question.
 
 
ROLAND F. HIRSCH
20458 Waters Point Lane
Germantown, Md. 20874-1091
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
                          RESEARCH
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Defense Giants Face Post-Cold War Research Challenge
 
TY  : RESEARCH
 
PG  : 15
 
 
Editor's Note: Now that the Cold War is history, it's clear 
that the United States' mighty defense and aerospace firms 
increasingly will be pursuing profit in areas other than the 
development of military weaponry. According to the 
newsletter Science Watch--published by the Institute for 
Scientific Information (ISI) in Philadelphia--the 
effectiveness with which these corporations refocus their 
product-development attention from swords to plowshares is 
likely to depend greatly on their basic scientific research 
capabilities. To gain insights on the research strengths of 
nine defense and aerospace giants, the newsletter undertook 
a study of their 1981-92 journal citation records. Following 
is Science Watch's report (4[1]:1-2, 1993), reprinted here 
with permission of the newsletter and ISI.
 
 
Many defense and aerospace firms in the United States and 
other nations are quickly discovering what it takes to 
survive in a post-Cold War world--and it's not business as 
usual.
 
 
As a wave of articles in financial and trade publications is 
telling us, many defense contractors have responded to 
slackening demand by selling off peripheral or weak business 
lines (often to their stronger competitors); by attempting 
to redirect their military manufacturing capabilities to 
civilian projects; and, generally, by downsizing.
 
 
To twist a familiar phrase, defense companies are starting 
to worry and learning how not to love the bomb so much.
 
 
During these times of turbulent transition, each defense 
company will be scrutinizing its scientific and 
technological base to determine how best to adapt to the new 
environment. While aircraft and weapons manufacturers are 
quintessential technology shops, technology is to some 
degree dependent on basic research and scientific expertise. 
The research activities of a firm may be only partly--or at 
times even poorly--reflected in the pages of the journals 
indexed by ISI for its Science Citation Index, especially if 
they represent proprietary knowledge or classified work that 
may be actively kept from public view. But even a partial 
picture may be sufficient to indicate areas of significant 
activity and strength.
 
 
With these limitations in mind, Science Watch reviewed the 
publication records of nine leading U.S.-based aerospace and 
defense contractors to assess their research performance 
over the last decade, to determine their relative rankings, 
and to identify areas of strength for each. All journal 
articles by these companies, published between January 1981 
and June 1992, were extracted from ISI's Science Indicators 
Database, and their citation counts were tabulated.
 
 
The results of this analysis show that Rockwell 
International Corp. and Lockheed Corp. stand out as the 
research leaders in the group. Papers from both companies 
attained the highest citations-per-paper averages (reflected 
in the citation impact column on the accompanying table), 
and their citation impact scores rose steadily since the 
period 1983-87. General Dynamics Corp., by contrast, 
achieved a relatively low, albeit consistent, altitude in 
terms of citation impact.
 
 
The table provides further statistics, such as the 
percentage of papers published from 1981 through June 1992 
that remained uncited by the end of June 1992, and the 
percentage of a firm's papers cited 25 times or more. Both 
tend to correlate with the ranking by citation impact. For 
example, Rockwell International, first in citation impact, 
exhibits the lowest percentage of uncited papers and the 
highest percentage of papers cited 25 times or more. General 
Dynamics, on the other hand, the lowest ranked in the group 
in impact, exhibits the highest percentage of uncited papers 
and the lowest percentage of highly cited papers.
 
 
Although all nine companies operate within the same business 
sector, their research activities differ significantly. And 
since different fields of research show different average 
citation rates, the rank order of the companies in terms of 
citation impact should be viewed as only a partial indicator 
of research strength. To the extent that any company 
publishes exclusively or disproportionately in a low-impact 
area, such as aerospace engineering, it would suffer in 
comparison to a firm that is active in one or more higher-
impact fields, such as condensed-matter physics.
 
 
What is perhaps the most telling scientometric statistic of 
a company's research strength is how its citations-per-paper 
record, at whatever level characteristic for its mix of 
research, changes against itself over time.
 
 
An examination of the highly cited papers for each company 
reveals the following:
 
 
* Rockwell International shows significant strength in 
semiconductor research, especially in studies of gallium-
arsenide materials, and in ceramic-based composite 
materials.
 
 
* Lockheed researchers have been particularly active in 
exploring the new high-temperature superconductors, as well 
as in a variety of astrophysical experiments in collab- 
oration with the National Aeronautics and Space 
Administration and academic institutions.
 
 
* McDonnell Douglas Corp.'s diverse research record includes 
studies of semiconductor materials, structures, and 
fabrication techniques; plasma physics; and lithium niobate 
materials.
 
 
* Martin Marietta Corp. scientists have been focusing on 
aluminum powder metallurgy technology; surface science 
topics, such as metal-polymer bonds; and plant science, 
especially photosynthesis.
 
 
* Raytheon Co. researchers published extensively on metal-
organic vapor deposition of thin films.
 
 
* Boeing Co. focused sharply on materials science and X-ray 
absorption spectroscopic studies of various compounds. Its 
researchers were also active in knowledge acquisition 
algorithms for expert systems.
 
* Northrop Corp. researchers consistently published papers 
dealing with pulsed excimer lasers, gyrotrons, and optical 
storage devices and pattern recognition.
 
* Grumman Corp. papers reveal a particular interest in A1-
based alloys, in photovoltaic cells, and in fusion research.
 
* General Dynamics researchers also explored A1-based 
alloys, as well as crack propagation in various materials 
and pattern recognition algorithms.
 
What, overall, are the main areas of research in the defense 
and aerospace labs? A study of the most frequently cited 
papers published between 1988-92 reveals the following 
subjects: condensed-matter physics, especially 
superconductivity; aspects of semiconductor science, 
especially GaAlAs/GaAs structures; thin-film preparation 
techniques; composite materials; optical data storage; and 
astrophysics.
 
Many pundits predict problems for defense contractors who 
hope to shift from military to civilian manufacturing. While 
the challenges are great, the specialized scientific and 
technological expertise these firms possess remains one of 
the U.S.'s most valuable assets. If these assets are smartly 
managed, they may produce significant returns, not just on 
the military side but on the civilian side of the economy, 
as well.
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : U.S. DEFENSE AND AEROSPACE CONTRACTORS
      (ranked by citation impact)
 
RANK      NAME  PAPERS  CITATIONS  CITATION  PERCENT  PERCENT    
                1981-82   1981-82  IMPACT    UNCITED  CITED 
                                                    +/- 25 TIMES
                                                       
   1  ROCKWELL  2,566    14,777     5.76     42.36     5.81
   2  LOCKHEED  2,534    11,962     4.72     45.30     4.18
   3  MCDONNELL 1,079     3,880     3.62     52.55     2.50
      DOUGLAS
   4  MARTIN      913     3,169     3.47     53.89     3.27
      MARIETTA   
   5  RAYTHEON     478    1,375     2.88     53.14     2.72
   6  BOEING     1,124    3,012     2.68     56.41     2.05
   7  NORTHROP     350      908     2.59     54.29     0.86
   8  GRUMMAN      453    1,010     2.23     58.50     1.32
   9  GENERAL      389      528     1.36     68.64     0.51
      DYNAMICS
 
Source: Science Watch/ISI's Science Indicators Database, 
January 1981-June 1992
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
                          RESEARCH 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : MOLECULAR BIOLOGY
 
TY  : RESEARCH (HOT PAPERS)
 
PG  : 16
 
 
X.-k. Zhang, B. Hoffmann, P.B.V. Tran, G. Graupner, M. 
Pfahl, "Retinoid X receptor is an auxiliary protein for 
thyroid hormone and retinoic acid receptors," Nature, 
355:441-6, 1992.
 
Magnus Pfahl (La Jolla Cancer Research Foundation, Calif.): 
"Thyroid hormones as well as the vitamin A-derived hormones 
(retinoids) influence a myriad of biological processes, 
including such complex programs as metamorphosis and 
morphogenesis. Retinoids have also drawn particular 
attention in recent years because of their effectiveness 
against a number of skin diseases (including wrinkles) and 
their potential  as  anti- cancer and cancer-preventive 
agents. However, use of retinoids and thyroid hormones as 
therapeutics has been hampered by undesirable side effects--
which, for instance, in the case of retinoids range all the 
way from slight skin irritations to malformation in fetuses. 
Because of the manifold roles of both thyroid and retinoid 
hormones, and their potential as therapeutics, their 
mechanism of action has been of particular interest.
 
 
"A major advance toward understanding this was achieved by 
the cloning of specific nuclear receptors. The receptors 
turned out to belong to a large family of transcription 
factors that also included the steroid hormone receptors. In 
concert with their multiple biological roles, multiple 
receptors were found to exist: two thyroid hormone receptors 
(TRa and TRb) and six retinoid receptors. The retinoid 
receptors fall into two groups, the retinoic acid receptors 
(RARa, b, and g) and the retinoid X receptors (RXRa, b, and 
g). Since these receptors were structurally related to the 
steroid hormone receptors, it was first believed that they 
also functioned like those--that is, bind as homodimers to 
specific DNA sequences (hormone response elements). However, 
it turned out that TRs and RARs (as well as RXRs) were 
relatively poor DNA binders but that their binding in vitro 
could be enhanced by nuclear protein extracts. This 
indicated that the mechanism of action was more complex and 
required another protein for efficient DNA recognition.
 
 
"In our paper we show that RXR is this nuclear factor. Thus, 
RXR, itself a retinoid receptor that requires 9-cis retinoic 
acid for activation, can serve as a coreceptor for TRs and 
RARs, receptors that belong to the same subfamily but are 
activated by very different hormones. An RXR homologue is 
already found in Drosophila (while TRs and RARs do not exist 
in insects) and has now also been shown to function there as 
the partner for the ecdysone receptor. Not surprisingly, 
then, its role in higher vertebrates turned out to be very 
broad, as RXRs were found to heterodimerize with the vitamin 
D3 receptor (VDR) as well as with the peroxisome 
proliferator-activated receptors (PPAR). Thus, RXRs play a 
very central role; by heterodimerizing with several hormone 
and vitamin receptors, they may in fact allow crosstalk 
between a variety of hormonal pathways and allow an enormous 
diversity of transcriptional controls. This may account for 
the pleiotropic effects of these hormones and vitamins.
 
 
"Because of RXR's central role, we were also particularly 
interested in the effect of RXR-specific ligands. 
Surprisingly, we observed 9-cis RA-induced RXR homodimers 
that act on a subset of retinoic acid-responsive genes (X.-
k. Zhang, et al., Nature, 358:587-91, 1992). Thus, an 
additional retinoid response pathway exists that is 
controlled by homodimers. We subsequently were able to 
design retinoids that are selective for RXR homodimers (J.M. 
Lehmann, et al., Science, 258:1944-46, 1992). Retinoids that 
induce RXR homodimers can decrease the RXR availability for 
heterodimerization, and we have recently observed that, 
indeed, 9-cis RA- and synthetic RXR-selective retinoids can 
inhibit the thyroid hormone response (J.M. Lehmann, X.-k. 
Zhang, G. Graupner, et al., Molecular and Cellular Biology, 
13:7698-7707, 1993).
 
 
"Overall, the discovery that RXR is an essential partner for 
a number of hormone and vitamin receptors by us (and several 
other laboratories at essentially the same time) reignited 
tremendously research in this area. A major challenge for 
the future will be to harness this knowledge into 
hormone/vitamin-derived therapeutics with optimal efficacy 
and minimal side effects. For the retinoids, this seems at 
last now to be feasible."
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : PLANT BIOLOGY
 
TY  : RESEARCH (HOT PAPERS)
 
PG  : 16
 
E.E. Farmer, C.A. Ryan, "Octadecanoid precursors of a 
jasmonic acid activate the synthesis of wound-inducible 
proteinase inhibitors," Plant Cell, 4:129-34, 1992.
 
Clarence A. Ryan (Institute of Biological Chemistry, 
Washington State University, Pullman): "The understanding of 
signaling pathways that regulate genes in response to 
environmental and developmental signals is a central theme 
in plant biology. How plants regulate genes in response to 
insect and pathogen attacks is important to the 
understanding of both intercellular and intracellular 
signaling circuits that are fundamental to the plant's 
survival, as well as in applying this knowledge to improve 
crop productivity. Recent research in our laboratory has 
revealed that an 18-amino-acid polypeptide called systemin 
as well as a small cyclopentanone called jasmonic acid and 
its methyl ester, methyl jasmonate, are powerful inducers of 
the synthesis of two serine proteinase inhibitor proteins, 
called inhibitor I and inhibitor II, that are synthesized as 
defense proteins in response to insect and pathogen attacks.
 
 
"We subsequently found that linolenic acid and two 
intermediates of the biosynthetic pathway between linolenic 
acid and jasmonic acid are also inducers of the two 
proteinase inhibitor genes when simply applied to the 
surface of tomato leaves. The various signaling compounds 
were incorporated into a hypothetical pathway for proteinase 
inhibitor gene activation in response to insect and pathogen 
attacks. In this model, extracellular signals released from 
attack sites, such as oligouronides (plant cell wall 
fragments) and the polypeptide systemin, are proposed to 
interact with the receptor cell membranes to activate a 
lipase. The lipase in turn is hypothesized to hydrolyze 
membrane lipids, releasing linolenic acid, which is rapidly 
converted to jasmonic acid. Jasmonic acid is proposed to 
interact with factors to activate the inhibitor genes.
 
 
"The model so far has been supported by several reports that 
have demonstrated an increase in intracellular jasmonic acid 
in response to wounding or to various defense signals in a 
variety of plant species. Jasmonic acid is now known to 
activate many other types of defensive genes in plants. The 
molecule had previously been shown to activate the synthesis 
of storage proteins in plant leaves and had been proposed as 
a plant growth and senescence regulator. Our paper, in 
presenting a model signaling pathway for jasmonate synthesis 
in response to signals, has generated a great deal of 
interest in the possibility that signaling pathways for 
other plant genes involving environmental and developmental 
signals may have similarities to those described in our 
model.
 
 
"As the model is more thoroughly understood, it should 
provide our first detailed understanding of a signaling 
pathway in plants in which signals that are produced by a 
known stimulus result in the activation of nuclear genes."
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
                     TOOLS & TECHNOLOGY
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : DNA Probes Yield Expanded Research And Clinical Uses
 
AU  : RICKI LEWIS
 
TY  : TOOLS & TECHNOLOGY
 
PG  : 17
 
 
As the growing numbers of molecular biologists well know, 
their art and laboratory craft depend on the extrusion of 
information residing in nucleic acid sequences. It follows 
that the tool that's come to be known as the DNA probe--a 
piece of single-stranded DNA that seeks out its 
complementary sequence in a biological sample--has become 
increasingly important to them.
 
 
The capabilities of probes have expanded rapidly in the past 
few years, and they have become easier to use. These 
developments have benefited not only basic researchers, but 
also those engaged in specifically directed investigations--
in diagnostics, forensics, and epidemiology, for example.
 
 
The technology's applications continue to increase, and DNA 
probes are now "well entrenched" in molecular biology labs, 
according to John Sninsky, senior director of research at 
Roche Molecular Systems, Alameda, Calif. In the research 
community, he says, investigators are being stimulated to 
use the probes in more and more "wild and wonderful ways."
 
 
A DNA probe may be a chain of as few as 15 nucleotide bases, 
the molecular building blocks of DNA and RNA, or it may 
stretch to thousands of such bases. The usefulness of the 
probe technology, researchers say, comes from the inherent 
tendency of these single-stranded nucleic acids to seek and 
hybridize to their complementary sequences, following the 
base-pairing rules that guide the formation of the DNA 
double helix--adenine with thymine, and cytosine with 
guanine.
 
 
A list of the methodologies dependent on DNA probe 
technology reads like a table of contents in a molecular 
biology text: Southern blotting (to detect other DNAs), 
Northern blotting (to detect RNA, measuring gene 
expression), colony and plaque hybridization (to spot 
bacteria and viruses), in situ hybridization (to highlight 
DNA sequences directly in cells), footprinting (identifying 
the sites where certain proteins bind DNA), mapping genes, 
and sequencing genes.
 
 
Even in the case of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), the 
widely used lab process that won its inventor Kary Mullis a 
1993 Nobel Prize, the primers used--short pieces of DNA--are 
essentially DNA probes bracketing sequences to be amplified. 
 
 
"DNA probes and PCR are inextricably linked at the hip," 
says Sninsky. 
 
 
Clinical Success, Research Staple
DNA probes are farther from the public eye than some other 
biotechnologies, such as cloning human embryos or 
genetically engineering tomatoes. They are nonetheless very 
much in the news, especially as diagnostic tools.
 
 
They were used, for instance, to help track down the sources 
of bacterial contamination in hamburgers served by a fast-
food chain that caused illness last spring, and they have 
been used to analyze contaminated municipal water supplies. 
DNA probes also helped researchers investigating the 
hantavirus pulmonary disease that struck the southwestern 
United States last year.
 
"They identified the virus initially using serology, but 
they quickly used DNA probes to identify the group of 
viruses to which it belonged," says Sninsky. The information 
showed that the condition had indeed been seen before.
 
Sninsky says that this capability of DNA probes to precisely 
identify a pathogen, even the particular strain of that 
pathogen present in a given patient, is a critical one. With 
both reemergent tuberculosis and AIDS, for example, the 
disease-causing targets of potential therapies are 
constantly changing, mutating to present new characteristics 
to researchers and physicians.
 
"Mutations are responsible for microbial resistance to 
drugs," Sninsky explains. "If you don't detect a drug-
resistant pathogen before you treat the patient, you could 
be exposing him or her to side effects without [a 
corresponding] benefit."
 
DNA probes were one of the first biotechnologies to 
successfully negotiate the passage from the laboratory to 
the clinic. One reason is that, compared with traditional 
microbiological detection tests, DNA probes generally offer 
both greater specificity and higher sensitivity. Also, the 
costs of most commercially available probe systems for 
specific targets range between about $150 and $400, making 
them affordable for many laboratories.
 
With standard tests, "there's a limitation in certain 
patients, where there is not enough antigen or antibody 
detected," according to Larry A. Risen, marketing manager at 
San Diego-based Gen-Probe Inc. "But with DNA probes, you can 
amplify material or use kinetics" to yield a diagnosis, 
Risen says.
 
Gen-Probe has focused its efforts on developing and 
marketing DNA probes targeted to common infectious 
disorders, such as those caused by streptococcus, 
enterococcus, Hemophilus influenzae, and several sexually 
transmitted diseases.
'A new probe-based test from Gen-Probe may help clinicians 
in their efforts to confront reemergent, drug-resistant 
tuberculosis. The probe is just entering trials in the U.S.,  
having  shown  in  European trials that it can greatly speed 
diagnosis over traditional culturing methods. Called the 
Amplified Mycobacterium tuberculosis Direct Test (MTD), the 
probe is capable of identifying the strain of tuberculosis 
present in about five hours, instead of up to eight weeks 
with the culturing methods, helping physicians prescribe 
appropriate treatments sooner.
 
"The test represents a breakthrough in adapting [this] 
technology to routine clinical use," said Mathew Longiaru, 
Gen-Probe's director of research and development, in a 
statement. "Designed specifically for the clinical 
laboratory, the test is not as burdensome as some 
complicated research methods."
 
 
Some companies focus on probes for research purposes, 
although they also may offer one or two for diagnostic uses. 
For example, Oncogene Science of Cambridge, Mass., offers 
research probes for a wide range of human genes, including 
interleukins, interferons, colony stimulating factors, 
myosin, tubulin, and oncogenes. The Food and Drug 
Administration also has cleared for marketing the company's 
Trans-Probe-1, which targets the site where pieces of 
chromosomes 9 and 22 join in 90 percent of patients who have 
chronic myelogenous leukemia. The classic test to spot this 
so-called Philadelphia chromosome, discovered in 1959 by 
Peter C. Nowell and David A. Hungerford (Science, 132:1497, 
1960), is to prepare a chart of all of the chromosomes, then 
search for the unusual joining--a much more painstaking 
task. 
 
 
Similarly, most products from Oncor Inc. of Gaithersburg, 
Md., whose specialty is in situ hybridization, are for 
research use only, but the company does have FDA approval 
for an in vitro diagnostic kit to detect rearranged 
chromosomes in certain white blood cell cancers.
 
 
Many DNA probes are available for research or 
investigational uses, but with clinical applications clearly 
in mind. GeneMed Biotechnologies, for example, offers probes 
to the human genes for beta globin, the cystic fibrosis 
transmembrane regulator, and key immune system proteins. As 
a group, these probes target inherited disorders. The 
company also markets infectious disease probes to the 
viruses causing hepatitis, herpes, and rubella, as well as 
the microbe that causes chlamydia.
 
 
Straddling the research-clinical line even more closely are 
the companies using FISH (fluorescence in situ 
hybridization) technology to speed fetal chromosome checks. 
The In-Sight system from Integrated Genetics of Framingham, 
Mass., highlights chromosomes 13, 18, 21, X, and Y--those 
most likely to be present in extra copies in fetuses--by 
using three to five DNA probes per chromosome. They offer 
this service on an investigational basis, as an adjunct to 
the conventional approach, which requires a week to culture 
cells from amniotic fluid. 
 
 
Brian Ward, director of the cytogenetics lab at Integrated 
Genetics, says that FDA approval for In-Sight is not 
required. FISH, he says, "is called `home brew technology.' 
FDA will only certify drugs and medical devices that are 
marketed and sold. It doesn't regulate services." He notes 
that states, however, may regulate such services.
 
Integrated Genetics' concentration on the chromosomal 
anomalies most commonly seen in fetuses reflects its 
clinical bent. But FISH technology also can distinguish 
among all 24 types of human chromosomes, making it useful in 
many research areas and in detecting rare or highly specific 
abnormalities. 
 
"It is the same technology, but using different sequences 
and different applications," says Ward. Researchers at 
Lawrence Livermore Laboratory in Livermore, Calif., for 
example, have developed what are called "whole-chromosome 
paints," which target repetitive DNA sequences. "These light 
up each chromosome from one end to the other. In contrast, 
ours are specific, brilliant, and intense, a small pinpoint 
of light in a nucleus," Ward says. Oncor's FISH system 
targets unique DNA sequences and currently identifies 19 
human chromosomes.
 
Oncor's newest probes detect genes currently at the 
forefront of genetic research, including those behind the 
Prader-Willi/Angelman syndromes, in which a small deletion 
in chromosome 15 causes differing symptoms depending upon 
which parent transmits it; and XIST, the site on the X 
chromosome that triggers one X to be shut off in cells of 
female mammals. They also have probes to telomeres, the tips 
of chromosomes that are important to their stability and are 
being intensively studied.
 
 
 
Farewell To Radioactivity
As a research tool, DNA probes are the latest in a long 
series of techniques to isolate and describe biological 
functions by labelling and tracking various biological 
molecules. Probes can carry different kinds of additional 
chemical marker units that allow researchers to locate and 
quantify them and their targets.
 
Although biologists and chemists have attempted to unravel 
various metabolic reactions since early this century, it 
wasn't until World War II that research in nuclear physics 
made radioactive materials readily available. This, in turn, 
allowed radiolabeling of biomolecules, and this led to new 
kinds of biological experiments. Radioactively labeled 
isotopes can be detected through their ability to expose a 
photographic emulsion on film, or by the alteration of the 
density of DNA incorporating them.
 
Many of the key experiments that laid the groundwork for 
molecular biology followed labeled DNA, for example. Often 
an isotope of phosphorus, 32P, was used, which labels the 
sugar-phosphate backbone of the molecule. The fact that the 
genetic material in a cell is DNA and not protein was 
discerned in the so-called blender experiments of Alfred 
Hershey and Martha Chase in 1950. They tracked and 
distinguished DNA by labeling phosphorus, and protein by 
labeling sulfur (A. Hershey, et al., Journal of General 
Physiology, 36:39-56, 1952). Matthew Meselson and Franklin 
Stahl later revealed the semi-conservative mode of DNA 
replication by differentially labeling nitrogen and 
following the densities of daughter DNA strands (M. 
Meselson, et al., Proceedings of the National Academy of 
Sciences, 44:671-682, 1958).
 
Using radioactive isotopes has obvious drawbacks, however. 
The beta particles emitted by 32P are so energetic that the 
signal on photographic film can be too fuzzy to be 
meaningful. Richard Rhodes, technical service representative 
at Promega Corp. of Madison, Wis., claims that his company's 
LIGHTSMITH I System, which uses chemiluminescence to label 
DNA, is much easier to use than traditional 32P labeling.
 
LIGHTSMITH is a direct, nonisotopic alternative to 
radioactive labeling, which means that the chemical that 
generates the signal is conjugated directly to the probe. 
Specifically, alkaline phosphatase is hooked to the probe. 
This enzyme catalyzes removal of a phosphate from a 
proprietary chemiluminescent compound. The resulting light 
emission marks the probe's presence. 
 
"You don't have to deal with handling or disposal, as you do 
with radioactive labels," Rhodes says. "And we've found that 
our probes display a higher level of sensitivity than 
radioactively labeled probes."
 
Another direct approach to tagging DNA probes is the Prime-
It Fluor Random Priming kit offered by Stratagene Corp. of 
La Jolla, Calif., which incorporates a fluorescently labeled 
nucleotide into the DNA. Commonly used fluorescent markers 
include fluorescein, which emits yellow-green when excited 
with blue light, and rhodamine, which emits a deep red.
 
Most nonisotopic labeling systems, however, are indirect, 
with the probe bound to a molecule that is attracted to a 
second molecule that is itself bound to the signaling 
enzyme, usually alkaline phosphatase. In the most common of 
these strategies, the DNA probe is immobilized on a support 
and bound to biotin (a small, water-soluble vitamin). Biotin 
binds strongly to the bacterial protein streptavidin, which 
is linked to alkaline phosphatase. Such streptavidin-
biotinylated DNA probes are offered by Genemed 
Biotechnologies Inc. of South San Francisco, Calif.; United 
States Biochemical of Cleveland; New England BioLabs Inc. of 
Beverly, Mass.; and others.
 
As popular as DNA labeling with biotin-streptavidin is, it 
is gradually being replaced by what some researchers say is 
a better alternative--digoxigenin, a derivative of the 
foxglove plant. 
 
The digoxigenin molecule binds DNA at one site and a highly 
specific antibody at another. The antibody is the part that 
is detected. Charles Schroeder, technical service specialist 
at Indianapolis-based Boehringer Mannheim Biochemicals, 
which produces digoxigenin, explains that its success is due 
to its uniqueness. 
 
"Many of our customers had noted that because biotin is a 
vitamin, it is endogenous to many [animal] systems," 
Schroeder says. "But digoxigenin is found only in the 
foxglove plant."
 
As a result, there is less background interference caused by 
the antibody binding elsewhere than to the DNA sequence 
labeled with digoxigenin.
 
 
Ricki Lewis is a freelance science writer based in Scotia, 
N.Y., and is the author of Human Genetics: Concepts and 
Applications (Dubuque, Iowa, Wm. C. Brown Communications, 
1994).
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : SUPPLIERS OF DNA PROBES FOR LABORATORY AND CLINICAL USE
 
TY  : TOOLS & TECHNOLOGY
 
PG  : 18
 
 
The following vendors develop and/or market DNA probes for a 
variety of research and diagnostic purposes.  For 
information about specific services, products, and prices, 
please contact these companies directly.
 
Accurate Chemical Scientific
300 Shames Dr.
Westbury, N.Y. 11590
(800) 645-3569
Fax: (516) 997-4948
 
Advanced Biotechnologies Inc.
9108 Guilford Rd.
Columbia, Md. 21046
(301) 470-3220
Fax: (301) 497-9773
 
American Type Culture Collection
12301 Parklawn Dr.
Rockville, Md. 20852
(301) 881-2600
Fax: (301) 816-4367
 
Biomeda Corp.
P.O. Box 8045
Foster City, Calif. 94404
(415) 341-8787
Fax: (415) 341-2299
 
BioServe Biotechnologies Ltd.
1050 West St.
Laurel, Md. 20707
(301) 470-3362
Fax: (301) 470-2333
 
Bio-Synthesis Inc.
612 East Main St.
Lewisville, Texas 75067-0028
(800) 227-0627
Fax: (214) 420-0442
 
Boehringer Mannheim Biochemicals
9115 Hague Rd.
Indianapolis, Ind. 46250
(800) 428-5433
Fax: (317) 845-2000
 
Calbiochem-Novabiochem Corp.
10394 Pacific Center Ct.
San Diego, Calif. 92121
(800) 854-3417
Fax: (619) 453-3552 
 
Cambridge Research Biochemical
Fairfax Research Center
Wilmington, Del. 19897
(800) 327-0125
Fax: (302) 886-5937
 
Cayman Chemical Co.
690 KMS Place
Ann Arbor, Mich. 48108
(313) 662-6756
Fax: (313) 662-6896
 
Cellular Products Inc.
872 Maine St.
Buffalo, N.Y. 14202
(716) 882-0920
Fax: (716) 882-0959
 
DAKO Corp.
6392 Via Real
Carpinteria, Calif. 93013
(800) 424-0021
Fax: (805) 566-6688
 
DuPont Biotechnology Systems
Barley Mill Plaza
P22-2278
Wilmington, Del. 19898
(302) 992-4785
 
FMC 
Bio Support Material
Group
200 East Randolph
Chicago, Ill. 60601
(312) 861-5900
 
Genemed Biotechnologies Inc.
458 Carlton Ct.
Suite B
South San Francisco, Calif. 94080 
(800) 344-5337
Fax: (415) 952-0447
 
Gene-Trak Systems/
Betagen/Imagenetics
31 New York Ave.
Framingham, Mass. 01701
(508) 872-3113
Fax: (508) 879-6462
 
Genosys Biotechnologies Inc.
8701-A New Trails Dr.
The Woodlands, Texas  77381-4241
(713) 363-3693
Fax: (713) 363-2212
 
Gen-Probe Inc.
9880 Campus Point Dr.
San Diego, Calif. 92121
(619) 546-8000
Fax: (619) 452-5848
 
Imagenetics
150 W. Warrenville Rd.
Mail Code F-2
Naperville, Ill. 60563-8460
(708) 420-5875
Fax: (708) 420-3845
 
Integrated Genetics
One Mountain Rd.
Framingham, Mass. 01701
(800) 255-7357
 
Life Technologies
8451 Helgerman Ct.
Gaithersburg, Md. 20884-9980
(301) 840-4150
 
Lofstrand Laboratories
7961 Cessna Ave.
Gaithersburg, Md. 20879
(310) 330-0111
Fax: (301) 948-9214
 
Microbiological Associates Inc.
Life Sciences Center
9900 Blackwell Rd.
Rockville, Md. 20850
(301) 738-1000
Fax: (301) 738-1036
 
Microprobe Corp.
1725 220th St., S.E.
Bothell, Wash. 98021
(206) 485-8566
 
Midland Certified Reagent Co.
3112-A W. Cuthbert Ave.
Midland, Texas 79701
(800) 247-8766
Fax: (915) 694-2387
 
National Biosciences Inc.
3650 Annapolis Lane
Suite 140
Plymouth, Minn. 55447-5434
(800) 747-4362
Fax: (612) 550-9625
 
New England Biolabs Inc.
32 Tozer Rd.
Beverly, Mass. 01915
(508) 927-5054, Ext. 309
Fax: (508) 921-1350
 
Oncogene Science
80 Rogers St.
Cambridge, Mass. 02142
(617) 492-7289
Fax: (617) 492-8438
 
Oncor Inc.
209 Perry Parkway
Gaithersburg, Md. 20877
(301) 963-3500
Fax: (301) 926-6129
 
Perkin-Elmer Corp.
761 Main Ave.
Mail Station 105
Norwalk, Conn. 06859-0105
(800) 762-4000
Fax: (203) 762-6000
 
Promega Corp.
2800 Woods Hollow Rd.
Madison, Wis. 53711
(608) 274-4330
Fax: (608) 273-6967
 
R & D Systems
614 McKinley Place, N.E.
Minneapolis, Minn. 55413
(612) 379-2956
Fax: (800) 328-2400
 
Research Genetics
2130 Memorial Parkway South
Huntsville, Ala. 35801
(800) 533-4363
Fax: (205) 536-9016
 
Roche Molecular Systems
Div. of Hoffmann-La Roche
1145 Atlantic Ave.
Alameda, Calif. 94507
(510) 814-2853
 
Sigma Chemical Co.
3050 Spruce St.
St. Louis, Mo. 63103
(800) 325-3010
Fax: (314) 771-5750
 
Stratagene Corp.
11099 N. Torrey Pines Rd.
La Jolla, Calif. 92037
(619) 535-5400
Fax: (619) 558-0947
 
Synthecell/Vega Biomolecules
7101 River Wood Dr.
Columbia, Md. 21046
(800) 336-7455
Fax: (410) 381-4965
 
Synthetic Genetics
3347 Industrial Ct., Suite A
San Diego, Calif. 92121
(619) 793-2661
Fax: (619) 793-2666
 
StressGen Biotechnologies Corp.
4243 Glandford Ave.
Suite 120
Victoria, B.C. V8Z 4B9
Canada
(604) 744-2811
Fax: (604) 744-2877
 
United States Biochemical
P.O. Box 22400
Cleveland, Ohio 44122
(216) 765-5000
Fax: (800) 535-0898
 
Zymed Laboratories Inc.
458 Carlton Ct.
South San Francisco, Calif. 94080
(415) 871-4494
Fax: (415) 871-4499
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
                         PROFESSION
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Corporate Board Membership: Enriching In More Ways Than One
 
AU  : ROBERT FINN
 
TY  : PROFESSION
 
PG  : 21
 
 
Imagine a position that requires a commitment of just four 
to 10 working days most years, yet pays up to $60,000--plus 
stock options. Imagine further that this position allows you 
as a scientist to observe the inner workings of the 
industrial culture of the United States, to make personal 
contacts with powerful businesspeople, and to influence the 
direction of a major corporation. Such is the lot of the 
scientists who sit on the boards of directors of public 
companies.
 
 
Allen Misher, president of the Philadelphia College of 
Pharmacy and Science, says of his work on corporate boards, 
"The quality of the people I deal with, the intellectual 
interactions, are extremely important to me and highly 
enjoyable. It gives me an opportunity to deal on a 
scientific basis with people at the forefront of their 
disciplines. It's even fun on a personal basis."
 
While the scientists who are asked to serve on corporate 
boards find the experience to be enriching from a 
professional as well as a financial perspective, some 
outside observers caution that such arrangements can lead to 
dangerous conflicts of interest. "In [a] company, the 
interest is in getting a product to market," says Sheldon 
Krimsky, a professor and chairman of the department of urban 
and environmental policy at Tufts University. "In the 
university, presumably, the main interest is the pursuit of 
truth."
 
A conflict can occur, for example, when a scientist with a 
financial interest in a company must evaluate research--
either in his or her own lab or on a peer-review panel--
related to the company's business, Krimsky says.
 
Yet Alan Schriesheim, director of the Argonne National 
Laboratory in Illinois and a member of two public boards--
those of Rohm & Haas Co. of Philadelphia and Hollywood, 
Fla.-based HEICO Corp.--says that when a scientist serves as 
a corporate director, his or her ability to function 
effectively as a researcher is enhanced. "It provides the 
scientist with a look at what one would consider to be the 
`real world'--what does it actually take to market and sell, 
and what are the risk/benefit trade-offs?" Schriesheim says.
 
"It gives you exposure to the very interesting problems 
industry has that require technical solutions. It's a 
generally broadening experience. The contact with other 
board members who are senior people in other industries--
banking, for example--makes the scientist a more rounded 
person. If he's an academic, it puts him in a better 
position to advise his students on career paths. It provides 
him with contacts that are helpful to his students and his 
colleagues."
 
"I look forward to [board] meetings," says Misher, who 
currently serves on the boards of three public companies--
U.S. Healthcare Inc. of Blue Bell, Pa.; U.S. Bioscience Inc. 
of West Conshohocken, Pa.; and MARSAM Pharmaceuticals of 
Cherry Hill, N.J.--and several private ones. "It's such a 
dramatic change of pace from the normal academic life that I 
find it extremely stimulating," Misher says. It's high-
energy, and decisions are made promptly." 
 
Of course, it is the rare scientist who gets to receive 
these benefits. Few corporations have scientists as 
directors. The ones that do--primarily those that are 
heavily dependent on technology--usually have only one 
scientist among the bankers, venture capitalists, and 
captains of industry who form the backbones of most boards.
 
 
Scientists At The Top
Generally, in order to be considered suitable to serve on a 
board of directors, a scientist must have established a 
national reputation on the basis not only of scientific 
achievements, but also of administrative and managerial 
skills. Furthermore, it helps to have spent a good portion 
of one's career outside the ivory tower. Misher, for 
example, spent 18 years with Philadelphia-based SmithKline & 
French Laboratories (now part of SmithKline Beecham), where 
he started as a pharmacologist and went on to increasingly 
responsible management positions, ending up as a group vice 
president. Schriesheim spent 27 years at the Florham Park, 
N.J.-based Exxon Research & Engineering Co. and two years as 
the director of Argonne before being asked to join his first 
board.
 
The administrative experience is important, because the 
responsibilities of a board member go far beyond providing 
the occasional nugget of scientific advice--many companies 
have scientific advisory panels for that. Board members need 
to be conversant with profit-and-loss statements, audit 
reports, and strategic plans, since they are charged with 
nothing less than overseeing all major corporate functions.
 
Mark P. Kriger, an associate professor of management at the 
State University of New York, Albany, and an expert on 
strategic management, says that the formal responsibilities 
of a board of directors include the following:
 
* maintaining, revising, and enforcing the corporate charter 
and bylaws;
 
* delegating special powers to corporate officers, such as 
the power to sign contracts, establish bank accounts, and 
sign checks; 
 
* approving important financial decisions, such as those 
pertaining to budgets, capital appropriations, and officers' 
compensation;
 
* examining the results of outside audits;
 
* safeguarding and approving changes to corporate assets;
 
* electing and advising corporate officers; and
 
* ensuring the maintenance of a sound board through regular 
elections and the filling of vacancies.
 
"In a legal sense, board members are the ultimate purveyors 
of the corporate charter," says Kriger. "They are legally 
responsible."
 
If a company is well run, these responsibilities can be 
exercised during the regular board meetings, which are 
usually held quarterly, or at most monthly.
 
"On occasion there are special assignments that might take a 
day or two longer," notes Misher. "In one company, another 
board member and I took on the assignment for the chairman 
of a very intensive review of their R&D efforts. With some 
outside help, that took us maybe a week's worth of sitting 
down and reviewing all of the R&D projects, very carefully, 
very intensively." But that's unusual.
 
"You each receive a `board book' a week or so prior to [a] 
meeting, providing a host of background on each of the 
agenda items," Kriger says. "This gives you the opportunity 
to read through it, think about it, [and] make a phone call 
or two if you're not certain as to some of the issues 
raised."
 
 
Legal Responsibilities
But if a company runs into trouble for one reason or 
another, the amount of work can increase greatly. Says 
Misher, "You've got to remember that, particularly in the 
state of Pennsylvania--and probably elsewhere--there are 
legal responsibilities. If you are the director of a public 
company, you are legally responsible for representing the 
best interests of the shareholders. That is a serious 
responsibility, and in order to execute that responsibility 
you must ensure that you are knowledgeable about the 
operations of the company and its controls and the way it 
manages its business."
 
Soon after Schriesheim joined the board of HEICO, a company 
that manufactures aircraft parts, there were some problems 
with management, and the board had to get intimately 
involved in the details of running the company. Recalling 
that experience, he says, "When a company is in trouble it 
sucks up a lot of time. If you're on the board of a public 
company and it's in trouble, you've just got to put in as 
much time as it takes, or you've got to get someone to put 
in the time. You've just got to be responsible to the 
shareholders. You could, for example, identify very quickly 
someone who could come in and turn things around. Or, 
alternatively, it could be months and months of long-
distance phone calls for hours at a time every day."
 
Even if a director meets his or her responsibilities with 
due diligence, in an increasingly litigious society there's 
the ever-present possibility of being sued. Notes Misher, 
"If you have a 15 percent drop in your share price for a day 
or two, computer programs will flash that to a whole host of 
plaintiff lawyers. You'll have class-action suits filed the 
next day. If you are a director long enough anywhere, you 
will find yourself in the middle of a class-action suit."  
 
Almost all companies provide liability insurance to their 
directors and officers to cover this contingency, but 
prospective board members should ensure that this insurance 
is adequate. "`Adequate' for me is usually $10 million on a 
personal basis, above the resources of the company," says 
Misher. "You are totally indemnified from liability in the 
conduct of your responsibilities for the company. But that 
indemnification doesn't hold if you can be found responsible 
for illegal, inappropriate action."
 
In addition, board members must be careful to avoid the 
appearance of a conflict of interest. In fact, Tufts' 
Krimsky thinks that actual or perceived conflicts of 
interest are so serious and so damaging that academic 
scientists asked to join a board should just say no.
 
Besides the obvious quandary that occurs when a board member 
is called upon to give a scientific evaluation of the work 
of a company in which he or she has a stake, conflicts can 
arise when a scientist directs a student to a particular 
area of research that may be of interest to the firm. 
Conflicts can become an issue when a scientist serves as an 
expert adviser to government agencies. And they can occur 
when the time a scientist spends working on company-related 
business detracts from the time he or she spends on academic 
pursuits.
 
Krimsky believes that if a scientist feels compelled to join 
a corporate board, in order to satisfy ethical 
considerations he or she must agree "never to take any 
government-funded research projects that are directly 
related to any work in the company."
 
Says Krimsky of the fundamental conflict of scientists 
joining boards: "If our universities are filled with people 
and departments who have multiple interests--not only 
academic interests but also financial interests in firms--
then we simply have no reservoir of independent opinion 
left. We can't get it from the companies. We're not going to 
get it from the government. And therefore what we're left 
with are very few places in which an expert can be 
considered by the public to have an independent role in 
society."
 
 
Financial Rewards
Serving as a director can be quite lucrative. Some Fortune 
500 companies pay $40,000, $50,000, or even $60,000 to 
directors. But smaller companies often pay much less. "The 
compensation can be substantial, but it can also be zip," 
notes Misher. "I serve on one board where the compensation 
is zero. I just get out-of-pocket expenses. It's a start-up 
company, and I said, `Look, I'll share the risk, I'll take 
some stock options. If the company succeeds, I succeed. If 
the company doesn't succeed, I get nothing.' But I really 
enjoy it. It's fun, it's exciting, they're doing great 
things, and I have great faith in the company. I'm getting 
my compensation in a variety of other ways."
 
Unfortunately for those scientists who would like to serve 
on a board, this is not a position you can apply for. "Board 
invitations are generally extended to those people who have 
made some reputation somehow," says Schriesheim. "They've 
gotten to be known for their technical work in a particular 
field, or for their advancement in a university to 
management and administrative posts, or for their government 
service. But usually, in my limited experience, saying that 
you'd like to be on a board and please won't someone ask me, 
is a way not to be asked."
 
Misher advises a scientist to have two kinds of meetings 
before deciding to join a board. "I would want to meet with 
the chief executive officer and the operating management of 
the company to assess their working relationship with the 
board, their openness, their understanding of what the 
board's responsibilities are, and to assess the 
`chemistry,'" he says. "If the chemistry doesn't work, 
forget it. This has got to be something you do less for the 
compensation than for the personal enjoyment. Secondly, I 
would want to meet with some outside members of the board to 
get a sense of their experience. How open is that board? Is 
this for show, or is it really a functional board? Does the 
board have a role that it actually plays in the company's 
business?"
 
Kriger adds that a prospective board member should consider 
the soundness of the company's finances and management. "You 
should be asking for substantial recent audits, but more 
importantly, you should be asking directors about their 
experience with the organization. What's it like to serve on 
the board? Do [the directors] like it? You should get a good 
feeling about the health of the organization. Are people 
openly disclosing things to you, or are they being 
protective? Any time your intuition is saying, `This doesn't 
feel right,' you really have to honor those feelings and 
follow them up."
 
Nonetheless, Kriger encourages scientists to become 
directors. "It can be very challenging, but it's potentially 
a very exciting thing to do, because you're being invited 
into the inside of this organization without being a full-
time member," he says. "There's a way in which, in its 
purest sense, directors function like the Solons of ancient 
Greek society--the wise men overseeing the organization. It 
can be a really fulfilling experience."
 
 
Robert Finn is a freelance science writer based in Pasadena, 
Calif.
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
                           PEOPLE
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  : Two Longtime Friends Share Tyler Prize For Their 30-
      Year Environmental Study
 
AU : PHIL BECK
 
TY : PROFESSION (PEOPLE)
 
PG : 23
 
 
F. Herbert Bormann and Gene E. Likens, whose ongoing, 30-
year ecosystem study has led to fundamental discoveries that 
have changed environmental law and international policy, 
have received the 1993 Tyler Prize for Environmental 
Achievement. The $150,000 prize, established by John and 
Alice Tyler in 1973 and administered under the auspices of 
the University of Southern California, was presented last 
month in Los Angeles.
 
 
The Hubbard Brook Ecosystem Study, centered in the White 
Mountain National Forest in New Hampshire, came about when 
Bormann, an agricultural scientist, joined forces with 
Likens, a zoologist, while they were both on the faculty of 
Dartmouth College in the early 1960s. Together they 
conceived and developed the idea of using a small watershed 
to conduct whole-forest ecosystem experiments. Through 
conventional scientific methods, long-term observations, and 
ecological modeling, they were able to test hypotheses in 
field experiments.
 
 
The pair discovered the phenomenon of acid rain (G.E. 
Likens, F.H. Bormann, et al., Environment, 14[2]:33-40, 
1972; G.E. Likens, F.H. Bormann, Science, 184:1176-9, 1974), 
which led to the first international symposium on acid rain 
and further studies on the subject throughout the United 
States and Canada. Research connected with the Hubbard Brook 
study played a major role in the development of the Clean 
Air Act of 1990.
 
 
Another Hubbard Brook study sparked national discussion of 
the effects of forest clearcutting, pointing out the loss of 
soil fertility and chemical degradation of stream water 
caused by this foresting method (G.E. Likens, F. H. Bormann, 
Ecological Monographs, 40[1]:23-47, 1970).
 
 
"We were using the chemistry of stream water much like a 
physician uses the chemistry of urine or blood . . . to 
judge the health of the whole forested landscape, and that 
turned out to be a very valuable way of proceeding," Likens 
says.
 
 
In an investigation with colleague Kathleen C. Weathers 
(K.C. Weathers, G.E. Likens, F.H. Bormann, et. al., Nature,  
319:657-8, 1984), they collected and analyzed cloud water, 
and showed that it was significantly more polluted than rain 
water. Their conclusions demonstrated that measuring air 
pollution must include cloud water inputs and dry fallout, 
in addition to acid rain. Their study led to the 
establishment of a North American network of cloud water 
research stations.
 
 
The Hubbard Brook study, supported by the National Science 
Foundation and the Forest Service, has attracted more than 
125 collaborators.
 
Bormann left Dartmouth in 1966 to join the faculty of the 
Yale University School of Forestry and Environmental 
Science, where he taught until his retirement in 1992. He 
remains Oastler Professor of Forest Ecology, emeritus, at 
Yale. Likens went from Dartmouth to Cornell University in 
1969, where he held several positions in the section of 
ecology and systematics, including chairman in 1982-83. He 
left Cornell in 1983 to create and direct the Institute of 
Ecosystem Studies in Millbrook, N.Y.
 
Although their academic paths have diverged, their 
collaboration has remained constant over three decades, 
which Likens attributes to several factors: "We both have a 
broad view of ecology, an ecosystem point of view," he says. 
"I think the fact that we brought very different strengths 
to bear made the team successful, and we were always able to 
think and write together, which I've found to be unusual."
 
 
Bormann, 71, earned his B.S. in agricultural science from 
Rutgers in 1948 and his Ph.D. in plant ecology from Duke 
University in 1952. Likens, 59, received his B.S. from 
Manchester College in Indiana in 1957 and his Ph.D. from the 
University of Wisconsin, Madison, in 1962, both in zoology.
 
Likens observes that public consciousness of the environment 
today is quite different from what it was when he and 
Bormann began their collaboration. "In the mid- to late 
'50s, if you mentioned that you were an ecologist on the 
main street of any city," he says, "they wouldn't have had a 
clue of what that meant. Now, of course, ecology and 
ecologists have become household words."
 
The reason for this change, Likens notes, is not necessarily 
good: "Everything you read and hear and see continues to 
talk about a continuing or new environmental assault on our 
living space. . . . There are new ones that crop up every 
day.
 
"I feel very strongly that the basic research that I do I 
want to have relevance to real-world problems, and I also 
care a lot about trying to communicate my scientific 
findings to decision-makers and the public."
 
--Phil Beck
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 
NEXT:
 
                          OBITUARY
 
 
------------------------------------------------------------
TI  :  LEWIS THOMAS
 
TY  :  PROFESSION (OBITUARY)
 
PG  : 23
 
 
Lewis Thomas, a noted biologist, physician, educator, and 
medical school dean who also was well known as an award-
winning author, poet, and philosopher on science, medicine, 
and other matters, died December 3 in New York of 
Waldenstrom's disease, a condition resembling lymphoma. He 
was 80 years old.
 
 
Thomas, who was president, emeritus, of Memorial Sloan-
Kettering Cancer Center and a professor, emeritus, at 
Cornell University Medical College at the time of his death, 
did research in the areas of immunology, virology, 
endotoxins, and histocompatibility. He published more than 
200 scientific papers.
 
The son of a doctor and a nurse, Thomas received his B.S. 
from Princeton University in 1933 and his M.D. from Harvard 
University in 1937. In the 1940s and early 1950s he held 
positions in the medical schools of Harvard, Johns Hopkins 
University, Tulane University, and the University of 
Minnesota, as well as the United States Naval Medical 
Research Unit during World War II.
 
He was a professor and chairman of the department of 
pathology at New York University-Bellevue Medical Center 
from 1954 to 1958 and was chairman of the department of 
medicine from 1958 to 1966. He was dean of New York 
University School of Medicine from 1966 to 1969, a professor 
and chairman of the department of pathology at Yale-New 
Haven Medical Center from 1969 to 1973, and dean of Yale 
University School of Medicine in 1972-73. From 1973 to 1980 
he was president and CEO at Memorial Sloan-Kettering; he was 
chancellor there from 1980 to 1983.
 
In addition, he held numerous positions with other medical 
schools, hospitals, foundations, societies, corporations, 
and government task forces and advisory committees.
 
Thomas's literary career began with poems he wrote for the 
Atlantic Monthly while still an intern in Boston. He first 
received wide recognition for essays, originally published 
in the New England Journal of Medicine, which were compiled 
in the book The Lives of a Cell (New York, Viking Press, 
1974), for which he won the National Book Award in 1974. 
Hundreds of thousands of copies were sold, and it was 
translated into 11 languages. That effort was followed by 
The Medusa and the Snail (Viking, 1979), which won the 
American Book Award and the Christopher Award; The Youngest 
Science (Viking, 1983), his personal medical memoir; Late 
Night Thoughts on Listening to Mahler's Ninth Symphony 
(Viking, 1983); Et Cetera, Et Cetera: Notes of a Word 
Watcher (Boston, Little, Brown, 1990), essays on language; 
and The Fragile Species (New York, Charles Scribner's Sons, 
1992).
 
He won numerous awards, including two that were named for 
him, the Lewis Thomas Award for Communications from the 
American College of Physicians in 1986, and the Lewis Thomas 
Prize from Rockefeller University in 1990. He received 20 
honorary degrees in science, laws, letters, and music. He 
was a member and an officer of a host of societies, 
including the National Academy of Sciences, the American 
Academy and Institute of Arts and Letters, the American 
Academy of Arts and Sciences, and the American Philosophical 
Society. 
 
 
(The Scientist, Vol:8, #1, January 10, 1994)
(Copyright, The Scientist, Inc.)
  
              ================================
 

 
